Originally posted by Palynka
Perhaps, I'm an anti-elitist elitist. I shun people like you, who believe that the majority of people are systematically incapable of appreciating good art when presented to it.
You are the sheep here, guided through prejudice into appreciating/disliking something just because others feel about it in a certain way.
Your shunning only encourages me. Although not prejudice per se, my experience has been that--- in areas where knowledge is preferred--- Naive Everyman is woefully ill-equipped to make a valued decision.
Were the command,"Look at the pretty colors," knowledge is not required and one knee-jerk is just as important as the next. Art can be reduced to that command, but that places my two year-old's finger paintings on the same level as any one of the masters' greatest pieces... maybe even higher, given her penchant for yellows and reds.
As our taste matures and we gain perspective and discernment, blacklight sci-fi posters are (typically) replaced with works of graduated expertise. This is what separates a Franzia from Chateau St. Jean Cinq Cepage and (depending upon the mindset of the one imbibing) elevates and enriches the level of enjoyment.
I shy away from the popular simply because my experience has taught me that the crowd is typically wrong. And, true to human nature, just when I think I have it nailed, the crowd picks a winner. In the case of Monet, the crowd (whether it knows it or not, or knows why or not) has it right.