Go back
Memory in hell?

Memory in hell?

Spirituality

e

Joined
17 Mar 04
Moves
82844
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Some members of our forum believe that memories of pain, suffering, loved ones left behind and so forth are no longer experienced in heaven.

Would the logic follow that memory in hell would be a certainty? After all, how better torture the unfaithful than to have them suffer untold anguish in the knowledge that they are forever separated from all that is good, especially loved ones!

Seems like quite a paradox!

b

Joined
16 Dec 04
Moves
97738
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by eagles54
Some members of our forum believe that memories of pain, suffering, loved ones left behind and so forth are no longer experienced in heaven.

Would the logic follow that memory in hell would be a certainty? After all, how better torture the unfaithful than to have them suffer untold anguish in the knowledge that they are forever separated from all that is good, especially loved ones!

Seems like quite a paradox!
sounds like the truth

e

Joined
17 Mar 04
Moves
82844
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by blindfaith101
sounds like the truth
In what way does it sound like truth?

t
King of the Ashes

Trying to rise ....

Joined
16 Jun 04
Moves
63851
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by eagles54
Some members of our forum believe that memories of pain, suffering, loved ones left behind and so forth are no longer experienced in heaven.

Would the logic follow that memory in hell would be a certainty? After all, how better torture the unfaithful than to have them suffer untold anguish in the knowledge that they are forever separated from all that is good, especially loved ones!

Seems like quite a paradox!
Doesn't sound much like a paradox to me. If you can believe the one you can believe the other just as easily. Personally, I don't think that memory as we know it can survive death. No more brain, you see. As the man says, you can't take it with you!

... --- ...

e

Joined
17 Mar 04
Moves
82844
Clock
19 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by thesonofsaul
Doesn't sound much like a paradox to me. If you can believe the one you can believe the other just as easily. Personally, I don't think that memory as we know it can survive death. No more brain, you see. As the man says, you can't take it with you!

... --- ...
How would it not be paradox to have memory in one eternal state and not in another? That would imply that God has set up greatly different mental recollective capabilities according to one's ultimate destination.

b

Joined
19 Mar 05
Moves
323
Clock
20 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by eagles54
[b]Some members of our forum believe that memories of pain, suffering, loved ones left behind and so forth are no longer experienced in heaven.
How could anyone know this? Do you know someone who has been to heaven, then returned to tell you these memories are no longer experienced?

t
True X X Xian

The Lord's Army

Joined
18 Jul 04
Moves
8353
Clock
20 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I don't think eagle is claiming this. Check out "Is heaven all that great if there is a Hell," for people who will claim to know this claim and may give you a reason. Notice I didn't say a good reason . . .

S

Joined
19 Nov 03
Moves
31382
Clock
20 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by eagles54
How would it not be paradox to have memory in one eternal state and not in another? That would imply that God has set up greatly different mental recollective capabilities according to one's ultimate destination.
It would indeed, but as god is supposedly onminpotent, this is not out of his league. I see no paradox here.

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89784
Clock
20 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by blueduck
How could anyone know this? Do you know someone who has been to heaven, then returned to tell you these memories are no longer experienced?
I've been to heaven.
I got hella drunk there too.
Obviously I don't go to nightclubs anymore, but the ladies were scantilly dressed. I was well impressed.

Pawnokeyhole
Krackpot Kibitzer

Right behind you...

Joined
27 Apr 02
Moves
16879
Clock
22 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
I've been to heaven.
I got hella drunk there too.
Obviously I don't go to nightclubs anymore, but the ladies were scantilly dressed. I was well impressed.
You didn't go to heaven the previous night if you don't feel like hell the next morning, right Shavixmir? 🙂

e

Joined
17 Mar 04
Moves
82844
Clock
22 Mar 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Starrman
It would indeed, but as god is supposedly onminpotent, this is not out of his league. I see no paradox here.
Wouldn't you think that God (not wanting to confuse we feeble-minded mortals) might stick to the same laws throughout his creation, including heaven and hell? Is God sensible and if not, why not?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.