09 Feb '12 01:05>
This is a moral philosophy poser for those interested. The most complete coverage I have found is at:
http://www.mercurynews.com/pacifica-news/ci_19914243
I am interested in your views on the moral transgressions and/or failures that apply to this incident; and who transgressed. There could be more than one.
Allegedly the violation was initially, walking a dog off leash where prohibited. It is not clear that a citation or arrest was imminent based on this one alleged violation. Subsequent alleged violations were: providing false information and refusing (repeated) orders to remain at the scene while identity was being checked. Allegedly the tasing took place after all of these three violations occurred. Reportedly he was eventually released without charges.
What is your opinion of the moral transgressions/failures? Who transgressed, what was the transgression or what were the transgressions, and under what moral theory or system do you find it to be a transgression? For example, consequentialism, duty theory, categorical imperative, Biblical Vedic, Kuran, etc. Please be as specific as you can. If you need to make any assumptions, please state them. If you rely on the Babcock information, please say so.
http://www.mercurynews.com/pacifica-news/ci_19914243
I am interested in your views on the moral transgressions and/or failures that apply to this incident; and who transgressed. There could be more than one.
Allegedly the violation was initially, walking a dog off leash where prohibited. It is not clear that a citation or arrest was imminent based on this one alleged violation. Subsequent alleged violations were: providing false information and refusing (repeated) orders to remain at the scene while identity was being checked. Allegedly the tasing took place after all of these three violations occurred. Reportedly he was eventually released without charges.
What is your opinion of the moral transgressions/failures? Who transgressed, what was the transgression or what were the transgressions, and under what moral theory or system do you find it to be a transgression? For example, consequentialism, duty theory, categorical imperative, Biblical Vedic, Kuran, etc. Please be as specific as you can. If you need to make any assumptions, please state them. If you rely on the Babcock information, please say so.