15 Jun '05 19:26>
Originally posted by ColettiThe intellectual prostituting that you do on behalf of these people is embarassing. You should at least get payed for your services. Arby Hill clearly states that every person has lied in their life. Then he jumps straight to the claim "all liars go to hell," implying that if you've told a lie, then you are a liar. Obviously, it was a silly post on Arby's part. He didn't think about what a strong adjective "all" is. Frogstomp pointed this out. Then Johnny Cochrane Coletti had to come in and cook up some lame story.
RB did not say that everyone who lies is a liar. He said that everyone has told a lie, AND liars will go to hell. You made the assumption that everyone who has ever told a lie IS a liar.
The point of making a logical statement is to first understand and THEN state the authors intent in logical form. So you should at least ask RB if he thinks everyone ...[text shortened]... dict himself by mistake, but in-so-far as his beliefs are Christian, they are not contradictory.
We all know from experience that Arby Hill believes that some people will go to heaven. The problem is he makes stupid statements without considering the implications. If he wanted to say what you mean then he should have written the following:
Every person has lied in their life.
Every liar who is not forgiven through Christ will go to Hell
Now you can squirm all you want in an attempt to make "some one who tells a lie" a "potential liar," but that is entirely Colettispeak. Arby Hill posts in English, not Colettispeak, so there is no reason to interpret his post in such an exotic manner.
My question to you is why can't you just except that Arby Hill made a silly statement and then move on. I suppose you xtians are in the habit of resurrecting dead things.