This is really hard to choose because I really like all these Quarterbacks for different reasons. They all have what it takes but they have had teams built around their playing styles. If you take each one out of their environments they probably wouldn't be as effective. At least for the first year or so, that is until you made some tweaks to fit their style. Each offense is very much different and would take a learning curve. Being a successful Quarterback is more than just lining up behind center and throwing the ball, it is getting the timing down with the receivers and knowing and trusting your Oline and their quirks. It would be like learning a new language in some ways. I guess what I am trying to say you can't plug a great Quarterback into a poor team and expect a super bowl victory. The only reason I wouldn't pick Favre as much as I really like him is simply longevity. He won't be playing many more years. It sure looks like he might but my gosh he is 38.
I believe Peyton Manning is the best of the QB's listed. Brady has the hot hand and Farve is going hot as well (although the last few years he was abysmal). Romo is still young and school is still out on him. Big Ben is solid, but erratic. But if I was going to choose the QB I would want in 3 years, it would be none of the above. VY would be my guy.
Originally posted by cashthetrashgreat points. the question is how would the QB's listed play if they were in the others offensive line?
This is really hard to choose because I really like all these Quarterbacks for different reasons. They all have what it takes but they have had teams built around their playing styles. If you take each one out of their environments they probably wouldn't be as effective. At least for the first year or so, that is until you made some tweaks to fit their vity. He won't be playing many more years. It sure looks like he might but my gosh he is 38.
Brady plays in a wonderfull system at the Pats...would he have the same numbers if he was with the Steelers etc...etc..?
How about Romo at Green Bay...without having TO to throw to?
Not knocking anyone but as cashthetrash said QB is not just about standing behind the Centre and throwing.
Originally posted by shortcircuitVince, Vince, Vince 🙂 I'm a Titans fan all the way, they started the season really good but the last 3 games Haynesworth, who was having a career year, has been injured which totally takes their effective run defense out. Hopefully he'll be back and the Titans can get rolling again.
I believe Peyton Manning is the best of the QB's listed. Brady has the hot hand and Farve is going hot as well (although the last few years he was abysmal). Romo is still young and school is still out on him. Big Ben is solid, but erratic. But if I was going to choose the QB I would want in 3 years, it would be none of the above. VY would be my guy.