Originally posted by uzless
No, I learned a tonne of things that weren't taught.
For instance, no coach can teach you that when you are skating toward the corner of a rink to get the puck to distinguish between the sound made by the skates of a normal forechecker coming at your from behind versus the sounds of the skates made by someone intent on putting your face through the boards.
Believe me, you cannot teach this, but you sure as hell learn it on your own.
I understand what you are saying about the nuances of a game and I agree whole-heartedly
that a player has a greater chance of picking up on these -- and maybe ONLY a player can pick
up on them, but that doesn't mean the player can't pass the knowledge on -- that doesn't
mean that a non-player can never learn these things. Because I just learned something about
hockey without having to play it - a nuance that not even a coach can teach (as you say) --
skates make different sounds on the ice depending on the intent of the skater. You passed this
knowledge on to us. Now, when I watch a hockey game I'll keep this in mind.
Does that mean I'll have the same
skill as you or another seasoned hockey player? No,
but that's not what we're talking about here. We're talking about knowledge of the game (if I'm
in the thread I think I am). Players can pass on knowledge about the nuances -- that's what
coaching and teaching is about. Knowledge can be passed on, even to someone who doesn't
play it. And in the other thread, when you explain the nuances of the hockey video, you'll be
passing on the knowledge to those of us who never played.