@very-rusty said
NO, You're suppose to be the Christian so you tell me what makes a good Christian.

If you have no answer I understand you just don't know? 🙂

-VR

I don’t have an answer as I’m not someone who uses the term “good Christian”. Nor do I use the term “good Catholic”.

Maybe try Google, see what you can find there.

@very-rusty said
The question was not directed at you gooster

You don’t seem to be very good at navigating open discussion Rusty.

@very-rusty said
@divegeester,
Would you consider yourself to be a good Christian? Do you follow all the rules of the Church?

-VR

I have no idea what your phrase “good Christian” means, perhaps you could define it please?

I’m not a member of any church which has “rules”; what type of “rules” do you have in mind?

@very-rusty said
Correct, and I am asking you what is a good Christian?

Example: Do you gooster consider yourself a good Christian?

-VR

The phrase isn’t one I’ve ever used, but you have done repeatedly.

Perhaps while you are thinking about what “good Catholic” is, you can also try to define what a “good Christian” is?

@medullah said
Unlike many other Christian sects/denominations/variations they don't take life. You won't get a JW pilot flying a mission for the US air force, bombing a fellow Christians in say Syria or Iraq, then writing it off conveniently as "collateral damage". They don't kill.

If the Christians in the European theater during WW2 had taken a similar approach one has to wonder if t ...[text shortened]... t the Jews, the JWs (after the Jews) were the second largest group to die at the hands of he Nazi's.

What biblical substantiation do you have for Christians, JWs, or any other branch of Christianity, being pacifists?

@very-rusty said
All I am doing is what you do a lot of the time is ask a question when asked a question. Irritating isn't it?

Not in the slightest.

You are talking about what makes a good Catholic, I’m asking you what a good Catholic is?

@very-rusty said
You sure seem to know much about religion for one who claims to be an atheist.

Why should being an atheist preclude someone from knowing a lot about religion?

@very-rusty said
What is a "good Christian"?

No idea; I’ve not mentioned the phrase so I’m not sure why you are quoting me on it.

@very-rusty said
I am sure there are Catholics who do not celebrate it either. I am not saying they are good Catholics how ever, but that is their own business, same as it is yours not to celebrate it.

What’s a “good Catholic”?

@very-rusty said
So not all Christians celebrate Easter? (Serious question)

-VR

Of course not!

@very-rusty said
You celebrate also Old Chap?

I’ve never celebrated Easter other than enjoying the extra days off work.

@very-rusty said
are you trying to work your way back into the "Ghost Chamber"?

Would leave if I did rejoin?

@very-rusty said
People sometimes try to include the whole Religion from what some are doing.

Like gooster for example a Christian? Not all Christians are as unkind as he is to people.

-VR

Awww come here Rustus, let me give you a big hug!

@very-rusty said
Your message NOTED: You don't have to keep repeating it.

I’m just replying to every time you asked me.

@very-rusty said
Fine talk for a so called Christian! I am sure the other Christians are so proud of you!

Easter is a pagan festival.

Google it; educate yourself old boy.