1. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295153
    15 Jun '18 08:151 edit
    I know a lot of you cannot sees my view on how Clan Challenge points are awarded
    See the results of the same challenges with the same results and how they are different
    How can the current system be tolerated
    challenge 1
    clan A clan B
    a W f
    b W g
    c W h
    d L i
    e L j
    Points awarded
    clan A 10
    clan b-10

    challenge 2
    a W f
    b W g
    points awarded
    clan A 4
    clan B -4

    c W h
    d L i
    e L j
    points awarded
    clan A -6
    clan b 6
    Total points awarded
    clan A -2
    clan B 2

    challenge 3
    a W f
    points awarded
    clan A 2
    clan B -2
    b W g
    points awarded
    clan A 2
    clan B -2

    c W h
    points awarded
    clan A 2
    clan B -2
    d L i
    points awarded
    clan A -2
    clan B 2
    e L j
    points awarded
    clan A -2
    clan B 2
    Total points awarded
    clan A 2
    clan B -2
  2. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344685
    15 Jun '18 08:25
    Originally posted by @padger
    I know a lot of you cannot sees my view on how Clan Challenge points are awarded
    See the results of the same challenges with the same results and how they are different
    How can the current system be tolerated
    challenge 1
    clan A clan B
    a W f
    b W g
    c W h
    d L i
    e L j
    Points awarded
    clan A 10
    clan b-10

    challenge 2
    a W ...[text shortened]... B 2
    e L j
    points awarded
    clan A -2
    clan B 2
    Total points awarded
    clan A 2
    clan B -2
    Great fair system currently in play.
    What are the random letters after games about???
    Still not found the site idea thread?
  3. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295153
    15 Jun '18 09:25
    Originally posted by @roma45
    Great fair system currently in play.
    What are the random letters after games about???
    Still not found the site idea thread?
    please take off those eye patches
    How can you say great fair system when you get three different results for the same games played ?
  4. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344685
    15 Jun '18 10:02
    Originally posted by @padger
    please take off those eye patches
    How can you say great fair system when you get three different results for the same games played ?
    Winner gets the points.
    Loser deservedly loses points.
    Drawn challenge both get equal points.
    How is that not fair?.
    Lose a challenge by one game or lose every game. The clan still LOST so deserve nothing it's like that in every game in the world.
    Really don't understand what you think is wrong with that even allowing for the fact you are not the brightest
    Again try sure ideas if you have a better idea.
  5. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295153
    15 Jun '18 10:12
    Originally posted by @roma45
    Winner gets the points.
    Loser deservedly loses points.
    Drawn challenge both get equal points.
    How is that not fair?.
    Lose a challenge by one game or lose every game. The clan still LOST so deserve nothing it's like that in every game in the world.
    Really don't understand what you think is wrong with that even allowing for the fact you are not the brightest
    Again try sure ideas if you have a better idea.
    Take off those eye patches
    If you look at the results I have given
    You will see three different amount of points awarded for the same results how can that be fair ?
  6. Subscribervenda
    Dave
    S.Yorks.England
    Joined
    18 Apr '10
    Moves
    59173
    15 Jun '18 11:43
    Originally posted by @roma45
    Great fair system currently in play.
    What are the random letters after games about???
    Still not found the site idea thread?
    The letters are representing players.For example the first challenge quoted(from memory) is players a to e down one side, W ,D, L (won drawn lost) in the middle and f to j down the other side.
    I really don't see the point of yet another debate about the points system.
    Wasn't there a vote last time this subject was aired?
  7. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344685
    15 Jun '18 11:47
    Originally posted by @padger
    Take off those eye patches
    If you look at the results I have given
    You will see three different amount of points awarded for the same results how can that be fair ?
    Your example makes no sense what are the letters meant to stand for?
    Seriously I don't see what the problem is
    Winners get rewarded end of story? .
    Still not found site ideas?
  8. Subscribervenda
    Dave
    S.Yorks.England
    Joined
    18 Apr '10
    Moves
    59173
    15 Jun '18 13:50
    Originally posted by @roma45
    Your example makes no sense what are the letters meant to stand for?
    Seriously I don't see what the problem is
    Winners get rewarded end of story? .
    Still not found site ideas?
    As I said above, the letters represent players. "a" could be tom brown "e" could be john smith so tom brown played john smith and tom brown won.
    Am I missing something or don't they teach basic algebra in Perth?
    I think they probably do in Dundee
  9. Subscribervenda
    Dave
    S.Yorks.England
    Joined
    18 Apr '10
    Moves
    59173
    15 Jun '18 13:52
    Sorry Roma, I see now you were answering Padge not me
  10. Subscriberradioactive69
    Fun, fun fun!!
    On the beach
    Joined
    26 Aug '06
    Moves
    55329
    15 Jun '18 13:55
    In any sport if a team gets beaten 5-0 or 1-0 the winning team still gets the 2 points. People with average intelligence or above get that, Unfortunately you don't Padger. Makes sense.
  11. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295153
    15 Jun '18 14:23
    Originally posted by @radioactive69
    In any sport if a team gets beaten 5-0 or 1-0 the winning team still gets the 2 points. People with average intelligence or above get that, Unfortunately you don't Padger. Makes sense.
    Have you got the same glasses as your " Captain "
    If you examine the examples I have given
    In each case the result doesn't change just the points awarded
    If they are different in each example then there is something wrong with the way points are awarded
  12. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344685
    15 Jun '18 15:52
    Originally posted by @venda
    Sorry Roma, I see now you were answering Padge not me
    Thanks buddy
    At least you explained what padgers random letters are for.
  13. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344685
    15 Jun '18 15:55
    Originally posted by @padger
    Have you got the same glasses as your " Captain "
    If you examine the examples I have given
    In each case the result doesn't change just the points awarded
    If they are different in each example then there is something wrong with the way points are awarded
    Are you having a laugh or just stupid?
    Points are awarded to winners. Following so far?
    But now listen very very carefully the larger the challenge the MORE POINTS than can be won.
  14. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295153
    15 Jun '18 16:12
    Originally posted by @roma45
    Are you having a laugh or just stupid?
    Points are awarded to winners. Following so far?
    But now listen very very carefully the larger the challenge the MORE POINTS than can be won.
    But in my examples all thought the results are the same the points awarded are different
    They should be the same
  15. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344685
    15 Jun '18 16:19
    Originally posted by @padger
    But in my examples all thought the results are the same the points awarded are different
    They should be the same
    There are not.
    I really don't understand what you are on about.
    The examples you show are for different amount of players in challenges.
Back to Top