Nirvana the last real band?

Nirvana the last real band?

Culture

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

S
The Mullverine

Little Beirut

Joined
13 May 05
Moves
8481
16 Sep 09

Can you think of a band in the last 20 years that changed the scope of rock and roll so profoundly?

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined
01 Jan 06
Moves
33672
16 Sep 09

Nirvana sucks.

Nirvana changed nothing but the sense of belonging of a clueless generation of mentally weak and musically impaired sniveling brats, too rich and comfy to really know what pain and desperation really mean.

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined
01 Jan 06
Moves
33672
16 Sep 09

===================THREAD CLOSED=======================

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by StTito
Can you think of a band in the last 20 years that changed the scope of rock and roll so profoundly?
The answer to your thread title question is no.

The answer to the question in the thread is no.

But both are not the same question.

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by Seitse
Nirvana sucks.

Nirvana changed nothing but the sense of belonging of a clueless generation of mentally weak and musically impaired sniveling brats, too rich and comfy to really know what pain and desperation really mean.
Your trolling sucks.

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined
01 Jan 06
Moves
33672
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by darvlay
Your trolling sucks.
Touched a nerve, uh?

I bet you still pilgrim to Seattle and get bent on top of his grave by some grunge-looking rear cowboy.

Butt boy.

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by Seitse
Touched a nerve, uh?

I bet you still pilgrim to Seattle and get bent on top of his grave by some grunge-looking rear cowboy.

Butt boy.
You're trying too hard. I'm just trying to help.

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined
01 Jan 06
Moves
33672
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by darvlay
You're trying too hard. I'm just trying to help.
There are different types of trolling.

I'm like the Kaufman of trolling, so to speak.

D
incipit parodia

Joined
01 Aug 07
Moves
46580
16 Sep 09
1 edit

Originally posted by Seitse
There are different types of trolling.

I'm like the Kaufman of trolling, so to speak.
Gerald Kaufman, you mean?

Edit (as it's a British thing): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Kaufman

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined
01 Jan 06
Moves
33672
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by DrKF
Gerald Kaufman, you mean?

Edit (as it's a British thing): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Kaufman
Andy.

u
The So Fist

Voice of Reason

Joined
28 Mar 06
Moves
9908
16 Sep 09
3 edits

Originally posted by StTito
Can you think of a band in the last 20 years that changed the scope of rock and roll so profoundly?
Nope. But what's really sad is that there hasn't been another band in the last 20 years to do so. 20 YEARS!! No other period in modern times (since the 50's) have we gone so long between a band (or bands) that changed the course of music.


Where is the new Messiah??

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by uzless
Where is the new Messiah??
Honest question here: Do you care if there's ever another so-called Messiah?

I don't. I'm at an age where I know what I like and I rarely go without new music to listen to. I don't think you'll find many kids out there who aren't savvy enough to find their own music, not like the days of old.

There will never be another Messiah.

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
16 Sep 09
1 edit

By the way, Messiahs are typically anointed by God, not record companies.

The Beatles are truly the only Messiahs of music who ever existed.

u
The So Fist

Voice of Reason

Joined
28 Mar 06
Moves
9908
16 Sep 09
1 edit

Originally posted by darvlay
Honest question here: Do you care if there's ever another so-called Messiah?

I don't. I'm at an age where I know what I like and I rarely go without new music to listen to. I don't think you'll find many kids out there who aren't savvy enough to find their own music, not like the days of old.

There will never be another Messiah.
Not sure that is the point. I'm talking about the future of music. Does it have one?


Pre 1950 - Motown records/Big band/classical music/Gershwin etc dominated
50's - The dawn of Rock and Roll..Chuck Berry and the guitar debut
60's - psychadellic music takes over...The doors, Pink Floyd, Jefferson Airplane, Velvet Underground, Beatles etc
70's - Hard Rock - Led Zeppelin, Sabbath, Who, ACDC
70's - Punk Music takes off.. Clash, Ramones, Sex Pistols
70's - Also see rise of Disco and Surf Music --Bee gees, Beach Boys
80's - Hair bands/Metal take over. Metallica/Def Leopard/Bon Jovi GNR etc
80's - Electronic music debuts - Petshop Boys, New Order Depeche Mode
90's - Alt Rock/grunge...Nirvana, PJ, Soundgarden, Smashing Pumpkins, Janes Addiction
90's Electrronic Music peaks with Rave explosion....Prodigy, NIN, Chemical Brothers etc

00's- Present.......who has taken over the mantle??? Can you name ANYONE??


EDIT: Yes, I do care because I get bored very easily of "new" bands that sound similar to what i've heard before. If you look at the chart above this, you can see pretty distinct sounds. The new bands of today sounds very similar to what has come before. Are we just out of new sounds? Is there nothing left to do? Have we reached what many people say happened to Art (paintings/sculpture) meaning that there was nothing left to paint or scultp that hadn't been done or re-interpreted already?

Is new music destined to just take from the proverbial parts bin of time from now on?

d

Joined
05 Jan 04
Moves
45179
16 Sep 09

Originally posted by uzless
Not sure that is the point. I'm talking about the future of music. Does it have one?


Pre 1950 - Motown records/Big band/classical music/Gershwin etc dominated
50's - The dawn of Rock and Roll..Chuck Berry and the guitar debut
60's - psychadellic music takes over...The doors, Pink Floyd, Jefferson Airplane, Velvet Underground, Beatles etc
70's - ...[text shortened]... ew music destined to just take from the proverbial parts bin of time from now on?
Everything is derivative from its predecessors. There was nothing entirely NEW about so-called Alt or Grunge or Punk or New Wave or Rave or Classic Rock. Everyone inspires everyone and it will go on forever.

As for the new bands with nothing left to do? They seem to be doing just fine...

Animal Collective
Abe Vigoda
Another Sunny Day
Arab On Radar
Atlas Sound
Autechre
Aphex Twin
Black Dice
Black Eyes
Blank Dogs
Blood Brothers
Boards of Canada
The Books
The Clientele
Clinic
Cold Cave
Daughters
Deerhoof
Deerhunter
Dillinger Escape Plan
Dirty Projectors
Dodos
Erase Errata
Erlend oye
Ex-Models
Exploding Hearts
Fever Ray
Fantomas
Field Music
Giddy Motors
Godspeed You Black Emperor
Gogogo Airheart
Grandaddy
HEALTH
Hella
Hot Chip
Isis
Jens Lekman
Joanna Newsom
John Zorn
King Khan
The Knife
LCD Soundsystem
Le Tigre
Les Georges Leningrad
Lightning Bolt
Love is All
M83
Monotonix
Mastodon
McLusky
Meshuggah
Microphones
Neon Blonde
No Age
Numbers
Oneida
Optiganally Yours
Owls
Panda Bear
Pissed Jeans
Plot to Blow Up the Eiffel Tower
Polvo
Ponytail
Shellac
Six Finger Satellite
Stereo Total
The Streets
Sunn o)))
Tortoise
Trans Am
US Maple
Ween
Wolf Eyes
Wild Beasts
Women
XBXRX
The xx
Yo La Tengo
Zach Hill


and on
and on
and on