Go back
America's dirty little secret

America's dirty little secret

Debates

Clock

Why do most developed countries have high speed rail, but not America??

How GM and corporate America killed our chances for high speed rail, and electric transportation.

American capitalism - Ain't it grand!




Clock

@mchill
I can see using high speed rail on the east coast, they are used to public transit. Once you get west of the Mississippi you run into people who drive cars.

Clock
2 edits

@eladar said
@mchill
I can see using high speed rail on the east coast, they are used to public transit. Once you get west of the Mississippi you run into people who drive cars.
HI speed rail has been proposed as an alternative to planes. I don't see this as being intended for public transportation in the same way NYC uses trains.

HSR would be more for long distance travel, like planes. They can offer a cheaper and more eco-friendly option.

Of course, it all depends on how fast, how much and how far.

Clock

@vivify

To cover the US there would need to be a southern, central and northern east west track and connecting tracks running north and south. That would be a lot of rail.

Clock

Clock

@eladar said
@vivify

To cover the US there would need to be a southern, central and northern east west track and connecting tracks running north and south. That would be a lot of rail.
Well thanks for explaining that to us.

Clock

@eladar said
@vivify

To cover the US there would need to be a southern, central and northern east west track and connecting tracks running north and south. That would be a lot of rail.
You don't need to start out with the whole US all at once. Just pick a few strategic places and expand based on how popular this turns out to be.

Clock

@vivify

Getting through the rockies is not easy.

Clock

@mchill said
Why do most developed countries have high speed rail, but not America??

How GM and corporate America killed our chances for high speed rail, and electric transportation.

American capitalism - Ain't it grand!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qaf6baEu0_w

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFhsrbtQObI
OSH regulation and environmental regulation.

Clock
1 edit

@eladar said
@vivify

Getting through the rockies is not easy.
Again, you don't need to cover every conceivable area of the US. Just certain strategic locations and go from there.

Clock

@vivify

I would think you would want to connect the two coasts.

Clock

@eladar said
@vivify

I would think you would want to connect the two coasts.
Maybe eventually.

Clock

@eladar said
@mchill
I can see using high speed rail on the east coast, they are used to public transit. Once you get west of the Mississippi you run into people who drive cars.
I think the idea is to give people a viable alternative to cars but the alternative has to exist before we give up our cars.
Given the choice between a claustrophobic car space and a smooth rolling train in which I can stretch my legs plus get myself a cup of tea and a big slice of cake I know which option I prefer.

Clock

@eladar said
@mchill
I can see using high speed rail on the east coast, they are used to public transit. Once you get west of the Mississippi you run into people who drive cars.
Wouldn’t a highspeed rail link between New York and say LA work?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.