Go back
Carmelo antony

Carmelo antony

Debates


@no1marauder said
I thought I already explained this to you:

""Disparity of force refers to a situation where your attacker, although unarmed, has such a significant physical or tactical advantage that a reasonable person in your position would fear death or serious bodily injury. In the eyes of the law, that overwhelming advantage acts as a weapon.

"In one Texas case, a man lawfully ...[text shortened]... tangent that Metcalf and Anthony were about the same size which the evidence shows is clearly false.
The person who stabbed her was 20 to 25 pounds smaller is it just like karmelo, or if you pushed them and they were 35 pounds smaller than you, can they stab you in the heart. The problem with you is that you research nothing, don’t listen to facts from anyone that goes against your activist mindset, extremely dishonest to see the bigger picture of what happened, who the aggressor was. You believe flake lies and bs and think you are actually saying something intelligent. Force returned must be the same, no fight just a one handed push on his left shoulder and an instant stab to the heart almost premeditated. This is what gave karmelo the balls to act and threaten like he was along with murder.


@no1marauder said
Untruths. He was in a tent talking to a friend who at least one witness said told him to come over.

A witness said a bully told him to leave or he'd "beat his a**" and he then said "touch me and see what happens". The bully had no authority to order him out of anywhere and the people who didn't like his presence there declined to go get a coach who was only 20 feet awa ...[text shortened]... tcalf did even having to go up multiple levels of bleacher seats to get to where Anthony was seated.
Might have started that way, but from testimony from everyone involved that is not how it ended with karmelo being and acting like the punk he was and threatening with a weapon to use it .


@mike69 said
The person who stabbed her was 20 to 25 pounds smaller is it just like karmelo, or if you pushed them and they were 35 pounds smaller than you, can they stab you in the heart. The problem with you is that you research nothing, don’t listen to facts from anyone that goes against your activist mindset, extremely dishonest to see the bigger picture of what happened, who the aggre ...[text shortened]... remeditated. This is what gave karmelo the balls to act and threaten like he was along with murder.
He warned, not threatened, in response to someone aggressively acting towards him who then attacked him. There was no "premeditation" just a perhaps excessive response to an assault by a larger person in a small area.

At most, manslaughter, but the trial was a farce given the judge's allowing the prosecutor to commit multiple legal infractions that severely prejudiced the (probably invalid) jury (because of the Batson violation).


@mike69 said
Might have started that way, but from testimony from everyone involved that is not how it ended with karmelo being and acting like the punk he was and threatening with a weapon to use it .
A bully messed with him, he told him to leave him alone and warned him not to touch him.

And if Metcalf hadn't touched him what would have happened?

Absolutely nothing.


@no1marauder said
He warned, not threatened, in response to someone aggressively acting towards him who then attacked him. There was no "premeditation" just a perhaps excessive response to an assault by a larger person in a small area.

At most, manslaughter, but the trial was a farce given the judge's allowing the prosecutor to commit multiple legal infractions that severely prejudiced the (probably invalid) jury (because of the Batson violation).
What a load of bs he definitely threatened, touch me and see what happens with his hand in his backpack on a knife not multi tool. Your argument is very dishonest like all libs. Are you going to answer my example?

1 edit

@no1marauder
You watch the police body cam when he said he told Austin to not touch him. Why did he run away after murdering Austin, and not just leave beforehand if he was in so much fear?

1 edit

@mike69 said
What a load of bs he definitely threatened, touch me and see what happens with his hand in his backpack on a knife not multi tool. Your argument is very dishonest like all libs. Are you going to answer my example?
Your "example" has nothing to do with the case, so no.

What would have happened if Metcalf hadn't touched him?

Warning someone not to commit a crime against you is a "threat" now?


@mike69 said
@no1marauder
You watch the police body cam when he said he told Austin to not touch him. Why did he run away after murdering Austin, and not just leave beforehand if he was in so much fear?
There's no obligation to retreat in Texas law.

There was machismo on both sides like I already said.


@no1marauder said
A bully messed with him, he told him to leave him alone and warned him not to touch him.

And if Metcalf hadn't touched him what would have happened?

Absolutely nothing.
Well thank goodness the judge and witnesses were honest and not stupid, unlike you. It was clearly a threat he actually did it without hesitation over a simple push. The action didn’t equal the returned force it was what murders do. Kids push all the time think of the death rates from murder with your ignorant mindset.

1 edit

@no1marauder said
There's no obligation to retreat in Texas law.

There was machismo on both sides like I already said.
Who said there was, you said he was in fear for his life over a one handed push, force has to be equal. Are you going to answer my questions about you and your wife and did you watch the video seen in court and police body cam just released?


@clown boy

Every witness said karmelo was the aggressor threatening multiple people asking him to leave. Him and his so called friend who was a friend of a girlfriend we’re not talking the whole time as you suggest he is a punk.


@mike69 said
Well thank goodness the judge and witnesses were honest and not stupid, unlike you. It was clearly a threat he actually did it without hesitation over a simple push. The action didn’t equal the returned force it was what murders do. Kids push all the time think of the death rates from murder with your ignorant mindset.
It didn't in the Caysen Allison case either but he was only convicted of criminally negligent homicide and got 10 years.

Claiming premeditation in this case is ludicrous given that nothing would have even happened if Metcalf hadn't assaulted Anthony in the first place. The case should have been a manslaughter at most.


@no1marauder said
It didn't in the Caysen Allison case either but he was only convicted of criminally negligent homicide and got 10 years.

Claiming premeditation in this case is ludicrous given that nothing would have even happened if Metcalf hadn't assaulted Anthony in the first place. The case should have been a manslaughter at most.
I can’t deal with your lying lib activist mindset, you run and make stupid comments ignoring anything said with stupid reasoning. You can’t prove anything you have said, you listen to other flakes like you. I’m glad the judge here wasn’t a wannabe like you.


@mike69 said
@clown boy

Every witness said karmelo was the aggressor threatening multiple people asking him to leave. Him and his so called friend who was a friend of a girlfriend we’re not talking the whole time as you suggest he is a punk.
All the witnesses? Including the one who gave a statement to police saying Austin Metcalf said he would "beat his a**"?

Everybody in the tent who testified were Memorial students and friends of Metcalf. They shaded their testimony beyond doubt but why should anyone take seriously claims that the guy who got pushed was the "aggressor"? It's ridiculous BS.

As far as I can tell, Anthony stood up to a bully who had no authority to tell him anything much less threaten and then assault him. I guess he's a "punk" to you because he was and is the wrong color.

1 edit

@no1marauder said
He warned, not threatened, in response to someone aggressively acting towards him who then attacked him. There was no "premeditation" just a perhaps excessive response to an assault by a larger person in a small area.

At most, manslaughter, but the trial was a farce given the judge's allowing the prosecutor to commit multiple legal infractions that severely prejudiced the (probably invalid) jury (because of the Batson violation).
Make me leave puss s, this is what he was saying g before Austin was there then touch me and see what happens (before the push) with his hand on a weapon. Metcalf said I’m not going to fight you here, and he wasn’t, just responding to a threat!! He doesn’t have to retreat and never thought he actually had weapon in his hand before the push. GFY

Austin was the team captain helping coaches.