Go back
Change The Constitution?

Change The Constitution?

Debates


@mott-the-hoople said
just an ignorant lie...the ar15 is not, and has never been used by the us military
The M16 and AR15 are the same rifle except for selective fire.

1 edit

@sonhouse said
@Metal-Brain
It can be used by the military IT IS NOT A CIVILIAN WEAPON AND YOU KNOW IT.
Semi-automatic-only rifles like the Colt AR-15 are not assault rifles; they do not have select-fire capabilities.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_fire


There are lots of things you need to change in your constitution.

I mean, considering teo sides can’t agree what the 2nd amendment means, is surely proof enough it’s written badly? Or, at least, with another time in mind.

A country with a standing army doesn’t need armed militias.
There is no way a centralized form of government meant that civilians should arm themselves to be able to fight that centralized government.
Who, exactly, is allowed to own which weapons on which settings?

And I’m sure each amendment needs a quick redo, now, 300 or so years later.

1 edit

@metal-brain said
Semi-automatic-only rifles like the Colt AR-15 are not assault rifles; they do not have select-fire capabilities.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_fire
That's one definition.
The term assault rifle, as used by civilian lawmakers and the general public has come to mean any military style rifle that is sold to civilians in semi-auto only.
Semi-auto AK47's and AR15's are no different than their military counterparts and are just as deadly.
Full auto fire is stupid, spraying and praying and running out of ammo after a one second burst is retarded....plus full auto fire is wildly inaccurate unless you have a lot of training.
It ain't like in the movies where you can hold down the trigger forever and never run out of ammo and hitting everything you wave the gun at.

1 edit

@jj-adams said
That's one definition.
The term assault rifle, as used by civilian lawmakers and the general public has come to mean any military style rifle that is sold to civilians in semi-auto only.
Semi-auto AK47's and AR15's are no different than their military counterparts and are just as deadly.
Full auto fire is stupid, spraying and praying and running out of ammo after a one s ...[text shortened]... hold down the trigger forever and never run out of ammo and hitting everything you wave the gun at.
assault rifle, military firearm that is chambered for ammunition of reduced size or propellant charge and that has the capacity to switch between semiautomatic and fully automatic fire.

https://www.britannica.com/technology/assault-rifle

Even if you accept that the definition is a semi-automatic firearm capable of accepting a detachable magazine I have to ask if the detachable magazine is what you have a problem with. Is it?

That is the only meaningful feature that makes it deadlier. You could make that with a 3D printer. You could make a large part of an AR 15 with a 3D printer.

https://3dprint.com/275348/3d-printed-ar-15-part-linked-to-extreme-right-boogaloo-group/

https://fortune.com/2019/02/14/man-who-3d-printed-an-ar-15-and-made-a-political-hit-list-gets-eight-years-in-prison/


@metal-brain said
assault rifle, military firearm that is chambered for ammunition of reduced size or propellant charge and that has the capacity to switch between semiautomatic and fully automatic fire.

https://www.britannica.com/technology/assault-rifle

Even if you accept that the definition is a semi-automatic firearm capable of accepting a detachable magazine I have to ask if the ...[text shortened]... com/2019/02/14/man-who-3d-printed-an-ar-15-and-made-a-political-hit-list-gets-eight-years-in-prison/
The best selling AR-15 magazine here has a 30 round capacity. https://www.cheaperthandirt.com/parts-and-accessories/magazines/ar-15-magazines/

This is a favorite accessory of mass shooters. You can get it for $7.97.


@no1marauder said
The best selling AR-15 magazine here has a 30 round capacity. https://www.cheaperthandirt.com/parts-and-accessories/magazines/ar-15-magazines/

This is a favorite accessory of mass shooters. You can get it for $7.97.
Biden said he wants assault weapons and high capacity magazines banned, or at least raising the age to 21 to buy firearms.

People have been 3D printing AR 15 magazines for about a decade now.


@metal-brain said
Biden said he wants assault weapons and high capacity magazines banned, or at least raising the age to 21 to buy firearms.

People have been 3D printing AR 15 magazines for about a decade now.
Not a single mass shooter has printed his high capacity magazine.

And so what? If they are banned and you print one and get caught, you'll go to jail (as you should).


@no1marauder said
Not a single mass shooter has printed his high capacity magazine.

And so what? If they are banned and you print one and get caught, you'll go to jail (as you should).
Mass shooters are largely suicidal. Do you dispute that?
Jail is the farthest thing from their minds. The reason men become mass shooters is because they feel people don't care about them and they hate people that are happy because they are the people who don't care about them.

In other words, it is a psychological issue. People are mean to different people. Capitalism is a kick down society.


Top ten I am now everywhere on this form.


@jj-adams said
That's one definition.
The term assault rifle, as used by civilian lawmakers and the general public has come to mean any military style rifle that is sold to civilians in semi-auto only.
Semi-auto AK47's and AR15's are no different than their military counterparts and are just as deadly.
Full auto fire is stupid, spraying and praying and running out of ammo after a one s ...[text shortened]... hold down the trigger forever and never run out of ammo and hitting everything you wave the gun at.
The term used by civilian lawmakers is "assault weapon" but your overall point is correct.


@metal-brain said
Mass shooters are largely suicidal. Do you dispute that?
Jail is the farthest thing from their minds. The reason men become mass shooters is because they feel people don't care about them and they hate people that are happy because they are the people who don't care about them.

In other words, it is a psychological issue. People are mean to different people. Capitalism is a kick down society.
Some are, some aren't.

I don't think psychological explanations are sufficient; there are suicidal people all over the world, but only the US has a disproportionate number of mass shootings. For example the US suicide rate is slightly higher than Belgium and slightly lower than Latvia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate


@no1marauder said
Some are, some aren't.

I don't think psychological explanations are sufficient; there are suicidal people all over the world, but only the US has a disproportionate number of mass shootings. For example the US suicide rate is slightly higher than Belgium and slightly lower than Latvia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate
Mass shooters don't usually expect to survive it when it is a school shooting or something like that. I suppose gang drive by shootings are mass shootings if they kill enough people so that is an exception. None of us can read minds, but the worst of mass shootings are psychological issues. Those are suicidal shooters as well as homicidal.

I would like to know if antidepressants are involved. It is well known that a small percentage of people taking antidepressants become homicidal and suicidal.


@no1marauder said
The best selling AR-15 magazine here has a 30 round capacity. https://www.cheaperthandirt.com/parts-and-accessories/magazines/ar-15-magazines/

This is a favorite accessory of mass shooters. You can get it for $7.97.
That is pretty cheap. People will buy them before a ban comes, so it wouldn't make much difference in the short term. In the long term people will 3D print them to get around it.

Banning high capacity magazines is a deterrent at best and I don't expect it to happen.


@Metal-Brain
Many children would be alive if just ONE thing change in gun law, raise the age to 21 to be able to buy a gun and I don't give a rats ass about your 'only if military age is raised to 21" BS. They are two separate issues and that will never even come into the debate by REAL adults Comrade.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.