Go back
College Female Fencer Refuses to compete against male trans

College Female Fencer Refuses to compete against male trans "woman"

Debates


@AverageJoe1 said
YOu make my point. A volunteer at the admittance table is approached by a guy who says he woke up a woman this morning. The volunteer says, cool, you will swim in Lane 6.
The parents of the girl with dreams of making the Olympics? The girl who is a shoo-in to win the competition and advance to the state finals, and then to Olympics in Paris................ They a ...[text shortened]... in the papers tomorrow, she will have nothing. She will quit swimming.
You are Marauderanne.
I wrote this scenario, which could INDEED happen, for god sakes. Marauder says, like my 14 year old grandaughter, says Well, ...it never happened!'

Just who is Maruder's revered authority at a swim meet? There are basically volunteers, maybe would-be competitors. Or liberal ones , who say the gender is irrelevant. brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr


@no1marauder said
The American Medical Association favors people being able to change their sex on their driver's license if they receive certain medical procedures.

You know more about such matters than medical professionals?
The "medical" profession, Makes a fortune mutilating kids. And BTW, this crap is the main reason Trump won. Keep up the stupid and the Dems will lose again. I hardly ever post, to much stupid going on, and I cannot bother debating stupid. And BTW the vast majority are not sucked into the stupid, again it is my firm belief that that is why Trump won.


@jimmac said
The "medical" profession, Makes a fortune mutilating kids. And BTW, this crap is the main reason Trump won. Keep up the stupid and the Dems will lose again. I hardly ever post, to much stupid going on, and I cannot bother debating stupid. And BTW the vast majority are not sucked into the stupid, again it is my firm belief that that is why Trump won.
Trump and conservatives don't care at all about the "mutilation". Just the gender stuff. They only focus on this one extremely rare surgery, and they lie about it.

Back surgery in kids is 100x more common, often unnecessary, often debilitating, and yet not one single Trump official cares. Trump won because he brainwashed you. You didn't vote to end child mutilation. You voted for incompetent liars.


@AverageJoe1 said
I wrote this scenario, which could INDEED happen, for god sakes. Marauder says, like my 14 year old grandaughter, says Well, ...it never happened!'

Just who is Maruder's revered authority at a swim meet? There are basically volunteers, maybe would-be competitors. Or liberal ones , who say the gender is irrelevant. brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
Since for some bizarre reason, AJ keeps bringing up this issue in unrelated threads by lying about my position, I'll repeat what I have said here (and basically the same thing in other threads):

"I've never said or suggested a man should be allowed to compete in a women's competition. But I do not accept this right wing assertion, contrary to established State laws and a SCOTUS decision, that a transgender woman is a man. Whether they should be allowed in women's sporting events should be up to the organizers' determination, based on medical and scientific evidence, as to whether they have some unfair advantage that cannot be mitigated by measures such as USA Fencing imposed here."

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said

"I've never said or suggested a man should be allowed to compete in a women's competition. But I do not accept this right wing assertion, contrary to established State laws and a SCOTUS decision, that a transgender woman is a man.
So what?


@no1marauder said
Since for some bizarre reason, AJ keeps bringing up this issue in unrelated threads by lying about my position, I'll repeat what I have said here (and basically the same thing in other threads):

"I've never said or suggested a man should be allowed to compete in a women's competition. [b]But I do not accept this right wing assertion, contrary to established State laws ...[text shortened]... y have some unfair advantage that cannot be mitigated by measures such as USA Fencing imposed here."
Sorry, all of your gender posts are over my head, I'm an 'at birth' guy, silly me.

As to events, .....on the other hand, you have never said that they should not be allowed to compete. From day one, you write about your preposterous 'it would be ok , if they are saying they are women' or some such crap. What were all of your sex links about? To prove what?
You can't keep this up, Marauder. You need to own up to this, you are losing cred.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.