Go back
GOP Bans More Books

GOP Bans More Books

Debates

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
First off, it's not the GOP doing this, it's the individual school districts and it's due to parents complaining about them. You don't know what the political affiliation of the concerned parents is.
Second off, they are simply removing them from school libraries, the books are still available, so they aren't being banned at all.
It is ALL GOP driven legislation
https://www.pewtrusts.org/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2022/01/13/librarians-decry-gop-moves-to-ban-books-in-schools
https://epgn.com/2021/11/11/the-gop-is-banning-books-now/
https://www.npr.org/2021/11/13/1055524205/more-republican-leaders-try-to-ban-books-on-race-lgbtq-issues
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
DUCKING the issue? Why ban ANY BOOK?
C'MON MAN, GROW A PAIR AND DEFEND YOUR BELIEFS/

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jimm619 said
DUCKING the issue? Why ban ANY BOOK?
C'MON MAN, GROW A PAIR AND DEFEND YOUR BELIEFS/
These books are being removed from school libraries due to inappropriate sexual content for young children.
They are not banned; you can buy one anytime you want.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
These books are being removed from school libraries due to inappropriate sexual content for young children.
They are not banned; you can buy one anytime you want.
But removed from the school libraries
by GOP 'thought police'.....right?
What happened to ''SMALL GOVERNMENT?''
Land of the free when it fits into your definition,
preaching morality...?....Separation of Church and state?
How pitiful that we should be frightened by true but maybe different thoughts
...I see you can't defend banning books except to say, ''you can buy them elsewhere.''...Thought you might have the courage of your
convictions , for an issue you obviously approve of.
.......Jerry Falwell is proud of you.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@jimm619 said
But removed from the school libraries
by GOP 'thought police'.....right?
What happened to ''SMALL GOVERNMENT?''
Land of the free when it fits into your definition,
preaching morality...?....Separation of Church and state?
How pitiful that we should be frightened by true but maybe different thoughts
...I see you can't defend banning books except to say, ''you can buy t ...[text shortened]... of your
convictions , for an issue you obviously approve of.
.......Jerry Falwell is proud of you.
No, they are being removed from different school districts because PARENTS are complaining.
It has nothing to do with GOP "thought police". It is being handled at the local level by PARENTS that don't want their children exposed to LBGTV smut in school.
What is your problem with that? Don't people have the right to control what kind of sexual literature their children are given in school?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
No, they are being removed from different school districts because PARENTS are complaining.
It has nothing to do with GOP "thought police". It is being handled at the local level by PARENTS that don't want their children exposed to LBGTV smut in school.
What is your problem with that? Don't people have the right to control what kind of sexual literature their children are given in school?
ALL GOP DRIVEN LEGISLATION
YOU KNOW IT
I KNOW IT
AND, EVERY READER KNOWS IT
Good men may differ, don't make fool of yourself..
Chaucer's, 'The Canterbury Tales?'...........c'mon, be honest
https://www.newsweek.com/arizona-gop-wants-books-like-canterbury-tales-banned-schools-1688844

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jimm619 said
ALL GOP DRIVEN LEGISLATION
YOU KNOW IT
I KNOW IT
AND, EVERY READER KNOWS IT
Good men may differ, don't make fool of yourself..
Chaucer's, 'The Canterbury Tales?'...........c'mon, be honest
https://www.newsweek.com/arizona-gop-wants-books-like-canterbury-tales-banned-schools-1688844
"Critics say it COULD BE used to ban books like The Canterbury Tales, Grapes of Wrath"....
Critics are adding their own slant to it, making up a lot of what MIGHT be, what COULD be, etc.
Let us know if any law ever does that, then you MIGHT have something to complain about.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
Don't care what's in Utah
The OP is about a book banning in Utah. I'm sticking to the topic.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
"Critics say it COULD BE used to ban books like The Canterbury Tales, Grapes of Wrath"....
Critics are adding their own slant to it, making up a lot of what MIGHT be, what COULD be, etc.
Let us know if any law ever does that, then you MIGHT have something to complain about.
What they MIGHT Do?
....What of your 'small government philosophy?'
....Does that mean you're O.K. with even a discussion of book banning?...Why will you not come out and say, that there is
'NO PLACE FOR GOVERNMENT CENSORSHIP ANYWHERE'
The First Amendment..........Remember that?
Say, you're not one of those folks who attend church
every Sunday, and contend that I'll burn in Hell
if I don't adhere to the rules of your particular faith?
There is only one rule...'The Golden Rule.'
As has been proven, again and again, 'you can't legislate morality.'
As I said, good men may differ but book banning is neither healthy for our children, nor the health of ANY democracy.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
The OP is about a book banning in Utah. I'm sticking to the topic.
No, it's gone way beyond the initial topic.
This thread is now a broken record, repeating the same arguments.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
No, it's gone way beyond the initial topic.
This thread is now a broken record, repeating the same arguments.
NO, SAME TOPIC
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Book banning by The GOP
You're stuck with an indefensible issue so,
as you say, its best we just, agree to disagree.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jimm619 said
NO, SAME TOPIC
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Book banning by The GOP
You're stuck with an indefensible issue so,
as you say, its best we just, agree to disagree.
Books aren't being banned .
Books are being removed from elementary schools because parents object to them.
Stop denying the truth.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
Books aren't being banned .
Books are being removed from elementary schools because parents object to them.
Stop denying the truth.
~~~ BANNED ~~~
~~ DEFINITION ~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1 : to prohibit especially by legal means
also : to prohibit the use, performance, or distribution of
a} ban a book
b} ban a pesticide
SEEMS ONLY ONE TRUTH DENIER HERE..
..Say, is a truth denier the same as a liar?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/banned

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jimm619 said
~~~ BANNED ~~~
~~ DEFINITION ~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1 : to prohibit especially by legal means
also : to prohibit the use, performance, or distribution of
a} ban a book
b} ban a pesticide
SEEMS ONLY ONE TRUTH DENIER HERE..
..Say, is a truth denier the same as a liar?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/banned
Your own definition gives lie to your problem:
YOU CAN STILL BUY WHATEVER BOOK YOU WANT, JACKWAGON.
You just can't put it in any school library you want.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jj-adams said
Your own definition gives lie to your problem:
YOU CAN STILL BUY WHATEVER BOOK YOU WANT, JACKWAGON.
You just can't put it in any school library you want.
Yes genius, they're called BANNED,
it OUR CASE, BANNED by The School Board(s).
You have a difficulty with facts, words what?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@jimm619 said
Yes genius, they're called BANNED,
it OUR CASE, BANNED by The School Board(s).
You have a difficulty with facts, words what?
https://www.pewtrusts.org/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2022/01/13/librarians-decry-gop-moves-to-ban-books-in-schools
https://epgn.com/2021/11/11/the-gop-is-banning-books-now/
https://www.npr.org/2021/11/13/1055524205/more-republican-leaders-try-to-ban-books-on-race-lgbtq-issues
~~ READ UP AND COME
............. BACK WITH FACTS TO BOLSTER YOUR GREY MATTER
https://www.msnbc.com/the-reidout/reidout-blog/conservative-book-banning-list-rcna7142
https://truthout.org/articles/gops-banning-of-books-and-attack-on-teachers-expose-the-partys-rising-fascism/
https://www.commondreams.org/news/2022/04/08/1100-banned-books-across-26-states-report-shows-shocking-censorship
https://www.wral.com/rally-against-banned-books-targets-gop-leadership/20163396/
https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/national-international/here-are-the-top-10-most-frequently-challenged-books-in-2021-according-to-the-ala/2854855/
https://bookriot.com/texas-book-ban-list/
https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/heres-the-long-list-of-topics-republicans-want-banned-from-the-classroom/2022/02