Go back
How would Jesus deal with Trans people?

How would Jesus deal with Trans people?

Debates


@suzianne said
ChatGPT-Written Bible Verse On How Jesus Feels About Trans People Sparks Discussion About What The Bible Actually Says About Gender

https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/chatgpt-written-bible-verse-jesus-011500420.html

Chat GPT has written a Bible verse on how Jesus might have dealt with a transgender person. The verse is thought-provoking and seems to capture the literary ...[text shortened]... ome narrow-minded Christians might see this as blasphemy, but to me, it sings with truth and beauty.
There's two kinds of trans people though, aren't there..?

Perhaps three...?

There are those born with intersex characterisrics that required guessswork from doctors to assign the right gender.

There are those who suffer from intense gender dysphoria and can only imagine themselves as the opposite gender in a positive light...

And then there are what I think is actually the majority of people: edgelords looking for attention and affirmation, who actively seek attention, who want to be part of something. Some of them are intensely autistic loners. Some of them are 'autogynophiles' or the female version of it, for whom there is an erotic inclination...

I think a lot of the non-binary folks are part of the ideological anti-gender crowd (a fourth category?) or, likewise, just generally mentally unwell attention seekers.

It's impossible to discuss the topic without these nuances.

And so I would think that Christ would make some distinctions here, as well...

Regardless: homosexuality is condemned.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@philokalia said
There's two kinds of trans people though, aren't there..?

Perhaps three...?

There are those born with intersex characterisrics that required guessswork from doctors to assign the right gender.

There are those who suffer from intense gender dysphoria and can only imagine themselves as the opposite gender in a positive light...

And then there are what I think ...[text shortened]... hat Christ would make some distinctions here, as well...

Regardless: homosexuality is condemned.
1. Guesswork
2. Imagine
3. Attention-seekers

You probably could have started with "I think it's all BS" like the rest of the supposedly Christian conservatives here.

So much for loving your brother as you love yourself. But I suppose that's what happens when people start thinking Jesus was too liberal.

Your last comment was like ending a discussion of Lego blocks with "But Teletubbies suck."


1 edit

-Removed-
I would think a more germane question would be "what does your experience of being an LGBT person tell you about being an LGBT person?"

But you can't score an off-topic "hit" with that, can you?



@jimmac said
You are 100% right about preexisting bias. I read it to mean, 1/- a MAN born without testis, 2/- a MAN that had his testis removed ( forcibly? ) that he might be suitable for purpose and 3/- one that chose so that HE might not be led into temptation. The last one would be the opposite of the modern highly sexualized Tranny. But your preexisting bias makes it hard for you to see this.
So you don't want them competing in chess tournaments?


@suzianne said
Meanwhile, with your pre-existing bias, that's all you see. Just like Mott.
Just like you, yes? you see, we are not so different after all. I acknowledge mine, do you acknowledge yours, nah, no way.


@sandpit45 said
So you don't want them competing in chess tournaments?
Huh?


@jimmac said
Huh?
It's a yes or no question. Or do you not care?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sandpit45 said
So you don't want them competing in chess tournaments?
Back again?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.