Go back
John Brown’s truth...

John Brown’s truth...

Debates

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120562
Clock
17 Mar 21
2 edits

Is it still “marching on”?

A global issue but I am admittedly highlighting the US due it’s size, influence, direct numbers of modern day slavery...and China for the same reasons (even worse) and also because of the symbiosis caused by the sheer volume of shared trade. Other counties are in widespread neglect and I will be challenging my own country to get its house in order too.

There is supporting data all over the web but I’ve used the Holy Guardian as a primary source as they are all over it and they also refer directly to the Global Slavery Index, also provided.

So either specifically or generally speaking, in your opinion...
John Brown; his body may be finished mouldering, but does his truth still march on?

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jul/19/us-modern-slavery-report-global-slavery-index (2018)

https://www.globalslaveryindex.org/

k
Flexible

The wrong side of 60

Joined
22 Dec 11
Moves
37304
Clock
17 Mar 21
1 edit

@divegeester said
Is it still “marching on”?

A global issue but I am admittedly highlighting the US due it’s size, influence, direct numbers of modern day slavery...and China for the same reasons (even worse) and also because of the symbiosis caused by the sheer volume of shared trade. Other counties are in widespread neglect and I will be challenging my own country to get its house in ...[text shortened]... 8/jul/19/us-modern-slavery-report-global-slavery-index (2018)

https://www.globalslaveryindex.org/
Yes his truth will always be with us.
But I’m getting the impression that the definition of slavery has changed over time and the dominant form today is more like extreme economic exploitation than the plantation model we normally discuss and that John Brown fought against.

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
17 Mar 21

k
Flexible

The wrong side of 60

Joined
22 Dec 11
Moves
37304
Clock
17 Mar 21
1 edit

The post that was quoted here has been removed
I’ve always regarded him as a hero of sorts but certainly an impulsive firebrand. Having said that, given the atrocities of plantation slavery, his fervour was more than justified and it was his lack of strategic ability that was his shortcoming and downfall.
I could be wrong but he was at least a rallying figure for the anti slavery movement and maybe still is.

D

Joined
09 Jan 20
Moves
3568
Clock
17 Mar 21

Funny how America is so evil but people from all over the world are clamoring to go there.

k
Flexible

The wrong side of 60

Joined
22 Dec 11
Moves
37304
Clock
17 Mar 21

@dood111 said
Funny how America is so evil but people from all over the world are clamoring to go there.
Are you posting in the correct thread. It’s been mentioned that the US is a long way from, being alone in the use, and exploitation of, modern slavery.
I’m not clamouring to get to the US, in case you were wondering. But if I lived in parts of Central and South America I probably would be in much the same way as economically distressed and war weary people in proximity to Europe are clamouring to get here. Who can blame them.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
17 Mar 21
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

The post that was quoted here has been removed
Some textbooks, sure. But that's not the way Brown was universally taught.

When I was in 9th grade, I remember reading Emerson's article on Brown that said that he made "the gallows glorious like the cross." This was assigned as part of a textbook.

To be sure, we also learned the counterpoint - we read people that thought that Brown was not justified. But I certainly wasn't taught that Brown was "extremely misguided fool (at best), a dangerous revolutionary, or a hateful lunatic."

This was circa ~1990.

PS: John Brown is honored quite thoroughly at Harpers Ferry National Historical Park. I can't speak for how he's viewed in the South, but as far as I grew up, Brown is viewed as something between a hero and someone who may have taken a good cause a bit too far.

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
17 Mar 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
17 Mar 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
17 Mar 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Philokalia

S. Korea

Joined
03 Jun 17
Moves
41191
Clock
18 Mar 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

The post that was quoted here has been removed
You spoke of Europeans admiring Tippu Tip insofar as they could admire a Muslim slaver.

I think that Americans admire Gen. Lee for many characteristics that go far beyond his allegiance to the confederacy.

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
18 Mar 21

HandyAndy
Read a book!

Joined
23 Sep 06
Moves
18677
Clock
18 Mar 21

The post that was quoted here has been removed
I would think that an amateur historian interested in truth and accuracy
would refer to a more reliable source than a Warner Brothers movie.

Earl of Trumps
Pawn Whisperer

My Kingdom fora Pawn

Joined
09 Jan 19
Moves
20423
Clock
18 Mar 21
3 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

@handyandy said
I would think that an amateur historian interested in truth and accuracy
would refer to a more reliable source than a Warner Brothers movie.
Americans believe their movies and their stars :-)

I remember as a youth, I read in the Sunday newspaper an interview with Vince Edwards,
the man who played Dr. Ben Casey in the uber popular weekly show by the same name.
And he talked about how so many people would meet him and begin asking him for medical advice lol.

That was somewhere around 1963 and even I, as a 12 year older, had to chuckle a bit at that.

D

Joined
08 Jun 07
Moves
2120
Clock
18 Mar 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.