@shallow-blue saidProve it.
Nonsense. You jumped on Putin's poodle's assertion because it fits your pre-existing presumption that Ukraine is ruled by Nazis and Russia is "liberating" it.
1 edit
Hitler's lawyer Hans Frank had been instructed by Hitler himself to find out if he indeed had Jewish roots according to Has Frank's memoir. The Nazi Party member claimed to have uncovered evidence that Hitler's grandfather was indeed Jewish.
This of course is disputed, but that seems to be the origin of the claim Hitler was part Jewish.
1 edit
@metal-brain saidWho’s protecting the Neo Nazis in Russia you halfwit.
To be fair the self proclaimed defenders of Jewish people are defending the neo nazis in Ukraine. Isn't the ADL pushing buttons by defending neo nazis?
https://www.lewrockwell.com/political-theatre/adl-defends-ukraines-neo-nazis-they-dont-attack-jews-or-jewish-institutions/
It seems to me that Jews are pushing their own buttons. The ADL is saying these nazis are good. The ultimate in hypocrisy.
Lavrov is a lying anti Semitic fascist pig who along with his Nazi boss wants to extend Moscow’s Neo Nazi regime into Ukraine and beyond.
There is not one single shred of evidence that Hitler was Jewish let alone consciously Jewish which he would have to be for this to be in any relevant and / or interesting.
This is just the pig Lavrov and his pig boss desperately trying to push their laughable De Nazification BS excuse for the murder and rape they are committing on innocent Ukrainian civilians who refuse to be enslaved by the sub human Moscow regime.
Perhaps NATO will one day get around to De Nazifying Russia 🤞
@metal-brain saidOh yes of course it’s ‘disputed’ as in BS
Hitler's lawyer Hans Frank had been instructed by Hitler himself to find out if he indeed had Jewish roots according to Has Frank's memoir. The Nazi Party member claimed to have uncovered evidence that Hitler's grandfather was indeed Jewish.
This of course is disputed, but that seems to be the origin of the claim Hitler was part Jewish.
@metal-brain saidhttps://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/05/03/roots-zombie-claim-that-hitler-had-jewish-blood/
Hitler's lawyer Hans Frank had been instructed by Hitler himself to find out if he indeed had Jewish roots according to Has Frank's memoir. The Nazi Party member claimed to have uncovered evidence that Hitler's grandfather was indeed Jewish.
This of course is disputed, but that seems to be the origin of the claim Hitler was part Jewish.
@kevcvs57 saidWell...to be fair, if Hitler's lawyer Hans Frank lied what was the incentive?
Oh yes of course it’s ‘disputed’ as in BS
That is all I am asking. What was his motive?
Maybe it is BS. I never said it wasn't. I am not making a claim either way, but this is a persistent rumor. Where is the evidence he was not part Jewish? Nobody seems interested in proving it to finalize it.
Is his paternal grandfather Jewish or not? Let's establish the truth so it is not disputed.
@sh76 saidThis last part is interesting:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/05/03/roots-zombie-claim-that-hitler-had-jewish-blood/
"But, in a possibly incestuous twist, Johann Nepomuk was also the maternal grandfather of Adolf Hitler’s mother, Klara.
When Alois was 39, almost two decades after Johan Georg’s death, Alois convinced a parish priest to alter the baptismal records and write in Johann Georg Hiedler as his father.
For reasons unknown, the last name was rendered in official records as Hitler."
1 edit
I'm going to fling this off the wall because I have no real basis for it, only a feeling.
We have watched Putin say that Ukraine is run by neo-Nazis, and listened to Kremlin spokespersons
declare that some Jews are anti Semites, Hitler was a Jew etc etc.
I think it's feasible that Putin may connect the two and say that Jews in Ukraine are the neo Nazis.
And they have to be taken out of Ukraine and sent to Russian reeducation camps.
Yup. Off the wall, I know.
@earl-of-trumps saidHere is another excerpt from the WP link sh76 posted.
I'm going to fling this off the wall because I have no real basis for it, only a feeling.
We have watched Putin say that Ukraine is run by neo-Nazis, and listened to Kremlin spokespersons
declare that some Jews are anti Semites, Hitler was a Jew etc etc.
I think it's feasible that Putin may connect the two and say that Jews in Ukraine are the neo Nazis.
And the ...[text shortened]... have to be taken out of Ukraine and sent to Russian reeducation camps.
Yup. Off the wall, I know.
"Many historians have speculated that either Johann Georg or Johann Nepomuk was actually Alois’s birth father, but the connections were covered up to avoid scandal. (Johann Nepomuk was already married when Alois was born.) No evidence has ever emerged to prove it one way or the other. Johann Nepomuk left Alois an inheritance. But, in a possibly incestuous twist, Johann Nepomuk was also the maternal grandfather of Adolf Hitler’s mother, Klara."
It is impossible to falsify. It is hard to confirm as well, but it does look very fishy.
That must be why Lavrov said Hitler was Jewish in his opinion. He also said he could be wrong before he said that, so it is opinion either way.
Conclusion: People who say the claim that Hitler was Jewish has been debunked are lying.
@metal-brain saidC'mon, metal brain, you have no proof
Here is another excerpt from the WP link sh76 posted.
"Many historians have speculated that either Johann Georg or Johann Nepomuk was actually Alois’s birth father, but the connections were covered up to avoid scandal. (Johann Nepomuk was already married when Alois was born.) No evidence has ever emerged to prove it one way or the other. Johann Nepomuk left Alois an i ...[text shortened]... er way.
Conclusion: People who say the claim that Hitler was Jewish has been debunked are lying.
@earl-of-trumps saidTrue, but there is no proof either way and what was the motive for Hitler's lawyer to lie?
C'mon, metal brain, you have no proof
Many historians have speculated that either Johann Georg or Johann Nepomuk was actually Alois’s birth father, but the connections were covered up to avoid scandal. (Johann Nepomuk was already married when Alois was born.) No evidence has ever emerged to prove it one way or the other. Johann Nepomuk left Alois an inheritance. But, in a possibly incestuous twist, Johann Nepomuk was also the maternal grandfather of Adolf Hitler’s mother, Klara.