Go back
make alcohol illegal

make alcohol illegal

Debates

E

Joined
06 Jul 06
Moves
2926
Clock
13 Jul 07

alcohol kills more people than any other drug; even people who never drink alcohol. it destroys your liver and your brain, and you can die from consuming too much of it; just like any other drug but it is downplayed for some reason; "it is only alcohol, its not a drug". if alcohol kills more people than any other drug, in my eyes it is the worst. so why are other drugs like marijuana illegal in the u.s.? i think you have to draw the line somewhere, but this line seems crooked 😕 since alcohol is worse than the other drugs, then they should be legalized or alcohol should be unlegalized. to me alcohol is a privilege; sort of like when the teacher in a school says "you can talk if you are quiet" and the class talks too loud so they lose that privilege and talking is banned in the classroom. well, people are irresponsible and had a chance with alcohol and people are still dying; so take it away.

M
Steamin transies

Joined
22 Nov 06
Moves
3265
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by EcstremeVenom
alcohol kills more people than any other drug; even people who never drink alcohol. it destroys your liver and your brain, and you can die from consuming too much of it; just like any other drug but it is downplayed for some reason; "it is only alcohol, its not a drug". if alcohol kills more people than any other drug, in my eyes it is the worst. so wh ...[text shortened]... are irresponsible and had a chance with alcohol and people are still dying; so take it away.
We tried that already.

Did you pause to consider that perhaps alcohol kills more people than any other drug simply because its the legal one?

l

Joined
18 Aug 06
Moves
43663
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by EcstremeVenom
alcohol kills more people than any other drug; even people who never drink alcohol. it destroys your liver and your brain, and you can die from consuming too much of it; just like any other drug but it is downplayed for some reason; "it is only alcohol, its not a drug". if alcohol kills more people than any other drug, in my eyes it is the worst. so wh ...[text shortened]... are irresponsible and had a chance with alcohol and people are still dying; so take it away.
I would say that the number of deaths is crooked. Everyone I know drinks alcohol to some extent. I know zero people who do hard drugs.

S
Evil Conservative

Joined
04 Jul 07
Moves
65533
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by EcstremeVenom
alcohol kills more people than any other drug; even people who never drink alcohol. it destroys your liver and your brain, and you can die from consuming too much of it; just like any other drug but it is downplayed for some reason; "it is only alcohol, its not a drug". if alcohol kills more people than any other drug, in my eyes it is the worst. so wh ...[text shortened]... are irresponsible and had a chance with alcohol and people are still dying; so take it away.
Cars kill and injure more than any drug, or terrorist(s) , or the action we are waging in Iraq. Lets ban cars.. and trucks. Oh yeah them plane crashes too.

Lets just all stay in our houses and never do anything where we might be injured or die.

And lets stop exhaling Carbon dioxide so we can lower our carbon footprints :-)

C

Joined
29 Jul 06
Moves
939
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

if they make alcohol illegal it wont stop people from geting it. people will always find a way to get what they want

w
Chocolate Expert

Cocoa Mountains

Joined
26 Nov 06
Moves
19249
Clock
13 Jul 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by EcstremeVenom
alcohol kills more people than any other drug; even people who never drink alcohol. it destroys your liver and your brain, and you can die from consuming too much of it; just like any other drug but it is downplayed for some reason; "it is only alcohol, its not a drug". if alcohol kills more people than any other drug, in my eyes it is the worst. so wh are irresponsible and had a chance with alcohol and people are still dying; so take it away.
1. Can you prove alcohol kills more people than any other drug? What about tobacco?
2. What about people who do use alcohol responsibly? Should they be punished, too?

I could see a reasonable argument for outlawing tobacco, actually, but not so much for alcohol.

a
AGW Hitman

http://xkcd.com/386/

Joined
23 Feb 07
Moves
7113
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by EcstremeVenom
alcohol kills more people than any other drug; even people who never drink alcohol. it destroys your liver and your brain, and you can die from consuming too much of it; just like any other drug but it is downplayed for some reason; "it is only alcohol, its not a drug". if alcohol kills more people than any other drug, in my eyes it is the worst. so wh ...[text shortened]... are irresponsible and had a chance with alcohol and people are still dying; so take it away.
We're a species which (like all of the higher apes) seeks to expand our experiential or mental horizons through drug use.
If it's not alcohol, it's tea or coffee, if not them, cigarettes, adventure sports, and excessive amounts of sex or masturbation.
Too many drugs being freely available is a bad thing, people will, as you say, probably end up being irresponsible in many cases. So we make what we can illegal. This is easy with marijuana or heroin or cocaine, just kill supply. To grow it at home, you need a seed and the right facilities. Alcohol though, you just need sugar, water, and bread-yeast, if you've none of that, just stick a lump of bread in the mix, it'll do the same job, just a bit slower.
That's why prohibition didn't work, they couldn't control supply effectively.
The solution? Legalise it, and impose restrictions like legal limits, when you can drive or not etc. Of course, many don't follow these guidelines, and laws, but compared to not having any control whatsoever over the amount of methanol poisoning, or the amount of money going to organised crime due to illicit sales of the easy to produce mead, etc. it's a damn sight better.

a
AGW Hitman

http://xkcd.com/386/

Joined
23 Feb 07
Moves
7113
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SMSBear716
Cars kill and injure more than any drug, or terrorist(s) , or the action we are waging in Iraq. Lets ban cars.. and trucks. Oh yeah them plane crashes too.

Lets just all stay in our houses and never do anything where we might be injured or die.

And lets stop exhaling Carbon dioxide so we can lower our carbon footprints :-)
Though a significant number of car crashes are as a result of alcohol abuse. Granted, we shouldn't live in fear, but I think it's a fair question to ask, why is this one legal while the others are not. Would you propose legalising coke or marijuana or prostitution (same end result, only it's a natural high and the dealer is the drug)

S
Evil Conservative

Joined
04 Jul 07
Moves
65533
Clock
13 Jul 07

Originally posted by agryson
Though a significant number of car crashes are as a result of alcohol abuse. Granted, we shouldn't live in fear, but I think it's a fair question to ask, why is this one legal while the others are not. Would you propose legalising coke or marijuana or prostitution (same end result, only it's a natural high and the dealer is the drug)
Actually, I'm a staunch conservative with some libertarian views. I think all drugs should be legalised, and then lets tax the hell out of them like we do tobacco, lessen the tax burden on the rest of us.

Now my proviso for doing the above is simply this, ridgid, unbending enforcement of the concept of personal responsibility. You get hooked on some drug and loose you job. Too bad.. you don't get any assistance, period. You cause injury or property damage while your enjoying you drug of choice, stiff penalties, automatically.

You kill someone while your drugged up, you experience the same fate. no questions asked.

If some charitable organization wants to help you get unhooked, fine, just don't the government state or local for any help. After all, when liberals say 'let the government pay for it' , they forget every legal citizen of the country is the government.

If my above suggestions ever took place (which they won't), it be interesting to see how many rational people would use drugs of any type.

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26751
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SMSBear716
Actually, I'm a staunch conservative with some libertarian views. I think all drugs should be legalised, and then lets tax the hell out of them like we do tobacco, lessen the tax burden on the rest of us.

Now my proviso for doing the above is simply this, ridgid, unbending enforcement of the concept of personal responsibility. You get hooked on some dr ...[text shortened]... hey won't), it be interesting to see how many rational people would use drugs of any type.
That all sounds perfectly reasonable.

a
AGW Hitman

http://xkcd.com/386/

Joined
23 Feb 07
Moves
7113
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SMSBear716
Actually, I'm a staunch conservative with some libertarian views. I think all drugs should be legalised, and then lets tax the hell out of them like we do tobacco, lessen the tax burden on the rest of us.

Now my proviso for doing the above is simply this, ridgid, unbending enforcement of the concept of personal responsibility. You get hooked on some dr ...[text shortened]... hey won't), it be interesting to see how many rational people would use drugs of any type.
Hmm, I too am quite conservative and libertarian simultaneously, but feel that you may be going a bit far there. It basically sounds like anarchy with a tax system. I think int he end, those who are responsible are the ones that will pay the higher price in such a system.

S
Evil Conservative

Joined
04 Jul 07
Moves
65533
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by agryson
Hmm, I too am quite conservative and libertarian simultaneously, but feel that you may be going a bit far there. It basically sounds like anarchy with a tax system. I think int he end, those who are responsible are the ones that will pay the higher price in such a system.
There would be details to be worked out obviously, but it bears some thought.

The possibility of removing the taking the $$$ away from drug lords, gangs etc Eliminating a large part of the cost we pay to fight against illegal drugs. Might warrant some study.

Of course, I wouldn't trust the people we have in Congress to come up with a workable plan, most can't put their shoes on without help. (I exclude a few from that statement) After all, look at the Immigration Reform Bill (Amnesty bill) they tried to foist on the American people

a
AGW Hitman

http://xkcd.com/386/

Joined
23 Feb 07
Moves
7113
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SMSBear716
There would be details to be worked out obviously, but it bears some thought.

The possibility of removing the taking the $$$ away from drug lords, gangs etc Eliminating a large part of the cost we pay to fight against illegal drugs. Might warrant some study.

Of course, I wouldn't trust the people we have in Congress to come up with a workable plan, ...[text shortened]... look at the Immigration Reform Bill (Amnesty bill) they tried to foist on the American people
Yeah, it strikes me as the kind of policy plan that couldn't be introduced overnight. Yes, lots of pro's but I can't see some of the details being workable in the long run. Definitely food for thought tho.

E

Joined
06 Jul 06
Moves
2926
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

if we legalize drugs for taxes, then the death rate caused by accidents will shoot up. do you think money can be traded for lives?

STS

Joined
07 Feb 07
Moves
62961
Clock
13 Jul 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Make alcohol illegal? My God.....what kind of monster would suggest such a thing? Have you never spent a leisurely afternoon drinking beer and throwing darts at the local pub? It's so wholesome, how could you deny anyone so minor a pleasure?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.