Originally posted by Metal Brain
Are speculators really the problem or are they convenient scapegoats?
http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/daily-ticker/4-gas-no-justification-high-prices-says-fmr-160209651.html
How much does supply and demand affect the price of oil and refined fuel these days and what is the cause of it?
Speculators do what the name implies, they speculate. They basically bet on the future price of commodities. Their bets are on the market, and the reaction to market forces. Actually, if anything their bets, their wins and losses tend to flatten out the actual peaks and valleys of the market. Saying or implying the futures traders control or force the market one way or the other is like saying betters at the Kentucky derby determine the winner, and how fast the race will be run.
What is regulated, and enforced in futures trading is insider information, which collusion would harm some speculators in favor of others. Even insider trading would have no effect on overall prices, only who made money on the futures trades.
If anyone has another explanation, I eagerly await hearing it. Too many otherwise intelligent people hear speculators maligned and go along without even thinking about how they could be involved in forcing gasoline prices higher.