Go back
The Pig that wants to be eaten.....

The Pig that wants to be eaten.....

Debates

k

Joined
16 Dec 04
Moves
2433
Clock
20 Jul 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

I've just read a very interesting book called "The Pig that wants to be Eaten and 99 other tought experiments.

One of the experiments is a poser that I think might create an interesting debate.

It is the future.....we have genetically engineered 'decerebated' chickens, they don't feel, are not self aware have no sense of environmant, pleasure or pain. They are basically vegetables, fed and watered but not really aware.

Would you feel different about eating this type of meat compared to regular meat?

As a vegetarian would you eat this type of meat? If not why not?

i

Felicific Forest

Joined
15 Dec 02
Moves
49438
Clock
20 Jul 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by kcams
I've just read a very interesting book called "The Pig that wants to be Eaten and 99 other tought experiments.

One of the experiments is a poser that I think might create an interesting debate.

It is the future.....we have genetically engineered 'decerebated' chickens, they don't feel, are not self aware have no sense of environmant, pleasure or pain. T ...[text shortened]... mpared to regular meat?

As a vegetarian would you eat this type of meat? If not why not?
If someone is a veggie because he doesn't like the taste and the looks of meat, he will not eat this chicken meat either.

But what will the more idealistic veggies decide ? ...... Ahaaa ..... 🙂


"They are basically vegetables, .... " 😉

r
CHAOS GHOST!!!

Elsewhere

Joined
29 Nov 02
Moves
17317
Clock
21 Jul 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ivanhoe
They are basically vegetables
I like my Terri steaks rare and frequent.

N

The sky

Joined
05 Apr 05
Moves
10385
Clock
21 Jul 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

"Are you going to tell me," said Arthur, "that I shouldn't have green salad?" "Well," said the animal, "I know many vegetables that are very clear on that point. Which is why it was eventually decided to cut through the whole tangled problem and breed an animal that actually wanted to be eaten and was capable of saying so clearly and distinctly. And here I am."

SS

Joined
15 Aug 05
Moves
96595
Clock
21 Jul 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
21 Jul 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

As a vegetarian I would have no moral qualms about eating that chicken but I still wouldn't eat it because:
a) It doesn't sound particularly appetising. Mmmm decerebrated chicken!
b) I don't miss eating meat at all.

googlefudge

Joined
31 May 06
Moves
1795
Clock
21 Jul 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

A more realistic, even probable (in our life time) scenario is 'vat' grown meat. Scientists are currently researching cloning and growing individual organs (no organ rejection or the need for organ donors) in the lab. Once this is perfected (and it should be viable within a few decades) it should be possible to grow meat, of pretty much any kind, at a much higher efficiency of resources then with actual animals and with no moral quandary.

C
Not Aleister

Control room

Joined
17 Apr 02
Moves
91813
Clock
21 Jul 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

I will enjoy eating tomatoes while they scream...

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.