Parents slam woke Massachusetts school district for axing advanced math classes to boost 'equity',
after they attracted too many white and Asian students - with families now forced to hire private tutors instead
Parents in Cambridge are speaking out after algebra was cut from middle school
Decision was made years ago due to racial disparities in advanced placement
But parents say it boosts inequality by forcing the use of private tutors
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12303157/Parents-protest-end-advanced-math-classes-Cambridge-middle-schools.html
------------------------------------------------
This story is big on this local level, as Cambridge is the home of Harvard and MIT,
so, sorry for the lack of good links, although more are out there. Use the Twitter, too, or the BostonGlobe . I cannot get into either.
@earl-of-trumps saidAt the Boston Globe site I can view the page source and glean this:
Parents slam woke Massachusetts school district for axing advanced math classes to boost 'equity',
after they attracted too many white and Asian students - with families now forced to hire private tutors instead
Parents in Cambridge are speaking out after algebra was cut from middle school
Decision was made years ago due to racial disparities in advanced p ...[text shortened]... s, although more are out there. Use the Twitter, too, or the BostonGlobe . I cannot get into either.
Recently, tempers flared again after the district said in an e-mail that middle school math staff would not “be recommending that any scholars place out of algebra 1″ in ninth grade. At a hearing of the School Committee’s curriculum subcommittee in May, a number of parents and residents argued for urgency. Critics say limiting advanced math has been counterproductive. “Not providing access means that the only people who will have access are the people who have outside means,” said Ross Benson, a math teacher who has taught advanced classes at Cambridge Rindge and Latin for 17 years, in an interview. Critics of the district policy note that without taking algebra in eighth grade, students must compress their math classes in high school in order to reach advanced classes like calculus. That means taking a year’s worth of math each semester. But that isn’t easy, said Bertha Pantoja, a parent in the district who had one son take algebra 1 in eighth grade and a younger son reach high school without it. “I have to get tutoring, like all the private school students, to help him,” Pantoja said. Tony Clark, cofounder and copresident of My Brother’s Keeper Cambridge, which works to support young people of color, noted the 6,600-student district has incredible resources and not that many students. “It’s a very workable number who don’t have [access] and really need it,” Clark said. “It’s kind of a put up or shut up moment.” In the background of all conversations about algebra in Cambridge is the Algebra Project, the math education program founded in the city by civil rights leader Bob Moses. Executive director Benjamin Moynihan was emphatic that with a combination of top-down policy and bottom-up support, Cambridge could teach all its students algebra in eighth grade. “Even despite the pandemic, is it possible? The Algebra Project would say yes,” Moynihan said. “It’s never going to be the perfect opportunity.” The Great Divide explores educational inequality in Boston and statewide.
Based on what's here, I really don't see the "equity" or "woke" angle. Often districts twiddle with curricula to streamline operations or save money/resources. It's a very small school district, I note.
Instead of axing advanced math they should seek ways to help lower income people afford tutoring, since they're citing that as the reason for the disparity.
But Soothfast pointed out that it's a small district so perhaps it's not a viable option for their budget. Even so, I don't see how cutting the program helps.
@Soothfast said - Based on what's here, I really don't see the "equity" or "woke" angle. Often districts twiddle
with curricula to streamline operations or save money/resources. It's a very small school district, I note.
---------------------------------
Thanks for that.
The Globe is the liberal paper so that does not surprise me. But think about it, a school cutting down
on its curriculum is counter productive. They are supposed to encourage people to dare to advance.
These people pay a lot of money to live in that city, as many move there so their children will be educated there.
And the school pills a stunt like this??? The administrators don't like looking at certain students advance
because they don't have the "correct" ethnicity/skin color??
@vivify saidIn the article I posted, the claim was that there were not enough "special people" enrolled to warrant running the course.
Instead of axing advanced math they should seek ways to help lower income people afford tutoring, since they're citing that as the reason for the disparity.
But Soothfast pointed out that it's a small district so perhaps it's not a viable option for their budget. Even so, I don't see how cutting the program helps.
Hmmmm,, Now suppose we cancel the football program because we can't get enough white people on the team... Ugh
What the hell, this country is chucked anyway.
@earl-of-trumps saidSleep is for folks with nothin’ better to do.
You can go back to sleep.
@soothfast saidInteresting. I first encountered algebra in 7th grade. Maybe just my school district.
At the Boston Globe site I can view the page source and glean this:
[quote]Recently, tempers flared again after the district said in an e-mail that middle school math staff would not “be recommending that any scholars place out of algebra 1″ in ninth grade. At a hearing of the School Committee’s curriculum subcommittee in May, a number of parents and residents argued for u ...[text shortened]... ricula to streamline operations or save money/resources. It's a very small school district, I note.
@earl-of-trumps saidSome parents are speaking out because resources were diverted away from advanced algebra for the few to basic math and other foundation courses for the many.
Parents slam woke Massachusetts school district for axing advanced math classes to boost 'equity',
after they attracted too many white and Asian students - with families now forced to hire private tutors instead
Parents in Cambridge are speaking out after algebra was cut from middle school
Decision was made years ago due to racial disparities in advanced p ...[text shortened]... s, although more are out there. Use the Twitter, too, or the BostonGlobe . I cannot get into either.
If MIT and Harvard are concerned perhaps they should spend some of their billions on outreach work identifying and tutoring these gifted future mathematicians.
@shavixmir saidGet with the programme shav, WOKE is code for Dems bad Reps good, racism good anti racism bad, LGBTQ folks bad, white supremacy good.
Sleep is for folks with nothin’ better to do.
@earl-of-trumps saidIt is a mistake to cut more advanced courses at a public school, I believe. Pare down the district administration instead. Bloated administrations are a blight on the academy in the US, from the lowliest kindergarten to the top research universities. It didn't used to be this way.
@Soothfast said - Based on what's here, I really don't see the "equity" or "woke" angle. Often districts twiddle
with curricula to streamline operations or save money/resources. It's a very small school district, I note.
---------------------------------
Thanks for that.
The Globe is the liberal paper so that does not surprise me. But think about it, a schoo ...[text shortened]... ke looking at certain students advance
because they don't have the "correct" ethnicity/skin color??
Some high schools that can't support more advanced courses on their own campuses have a relationship with a nearby community college so that Johnny can take differential equations or linear algebra there. That's another way to go.
@soothfast saidSchools in the US have their budgets tied to property tax (another great American idea). I don't know what their budget is and what was saved because of this cut (maybe it was indeed the bonus of some bloated administrator)
It is a mistake to cut more advanced courses at a public school, I believe. Pare down the district administration instead. Bloated administrations are a blight on the academy in the US, from the lowliest kindergarten to the top research universities. It didn't used to be this way.
Some high schools that can't support more advanced courses on their own campuses have a ...[text shortened]... e so that Johnny can take differential equations or linear algebra there. That's another way to go.
Fun fact: i had a kinda mathematically challenged friend in middle school. When he emmigrated to the US he was suddenly top of his class because he had already learned everything thought in his age group 1 or 2 years prior in Romania.
I don't know what constitutes as "advanced algebra" in the US. What i do know is that allowing each county school board to decide what is being thought in schools and that the money available is tied to how rich the parents in that neighborhood are is lunacy.
@zahlanzi saidI wasn't sure to what degree property taxes fund US public schools, but scrolling down here gives a percentage by state in a big map:
Schools in the US have their budgets tied to property tax (another great American idea). I don't know what their budget is and what was saved because of this cut (maybe it was indeed the bonus of some bloated administrator)
Fun fact: i had a kinda mathematically challenged friend in middle school. When he emmigrated to the US he was suddenly top of his class because he ...[text shortened]... ols and that the money available is tied to how rich the parents in that neighborhood are is lunacy.
https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cma/public-school-revenue
Only in Vermont and Hawaii are school budgets not dependent on property taxes, at least for practical purposes. There are a smattering of other states where the percentage is in the 10% to 20% range. New Hampshire is the highest at 62%.
Anyway, I don't know what this "advanced algebra" is about. I assume it's some kind of AP (Advanced Placement) algebra course. It's not likely anything remotely to do with what mathematicians mean by advanced algebra, otherwise known as abstract algebra, which studies groups, rings, fields, and other algebraic structures.