29 Mar 05
Originally posted by STANGCan you please be more specific than "Americans"? Do you mean Politicians? Conservatives? What?
Americans kill people for capital punishment and to bring people democracy ... yet argue over euthanasia. Where there is a will there is a way out.
Surely you're not suggesting that all Americans have one streamlined school of thought.
Then again, you are STANG. 😛
29 Mar 05
Originally posted by STANGGood ol STANG. Well a welcome back is in order I suppose. Did you get banned again?
Americans kill people for capital punishment and to bring people democracy ... yet argue over euthanasia. Where there is a will there is a way out.
And Darvlay's right, you shouldn't say Americans. There are plenty of states in America that don't execute people. Lots of politicians that take a stand against capital punishment. And millions of citizens here that are against it also. So don't just lump everyone into some great big pot and label us all the same. I dare say you'd ever find a more diverse group of people than Americans.
29 Mar 05
Originally posted by wibPlease accept my apologies. We've got the same problem with euthanasia in Australia, though we don't allow capital punishment in any states and we don't initiate invasions and killings for the sake of democracy. My question concerns national behaviour, with America allowing capital punishment in at least some of its states and killings for the sake of democracy. If you support my arguement then you'd be less critical. What about those that don't ?
Good ol STANG. Well a welcome back is in order I suppose. Did you get banned again?
And Darvlay's right, you shouldn't say Americans. There are plenty of states in America that don't execute people. Lots of politicians that take a stand against capital punishment. And millions of citizens here that are against it also. So don't just lump everyone in ...[text shortened]... l us all the same. I dare say you'd ever find a more diverse group of people than Americans.
30 Mar 05
Originally posted by STANGI rest my case !
Please accept my apologies. We've got the same problem with euthanasia in Australia, though we don't allow capital punishment in any states and we don't initiate invasions and killings for the sake of democracy. My question concerns national behaviour, with America allowing capital punishment in at least some of its states and killings for the sake of democracy. If you support my arguement then you'd be less critical. What about those that don't ?
30 Mar 05
Originally posted by STANGeuthanasia and capital punishment arent really similar enough for it to be ironic - euthanasia is (we would hope) compassionate, whereas capital punishment is not, so therefore they shouldnt necessarily be treated in the same way; you cant generalise the behaviour appropriate to one to the other (if u get what i mean).
What's your thoughts on the irony ?
not that the behaviour deemed 'appropriate' is necessarily 'right' of course, but thats another debate
marcus
30 Mar 05
Originally posted by OuermyhteThat's kind of the whole point behind the irony. They will happily kill as punishment, but not out of compassion.
euthanasia and capital punishment arent really similar enough for it to be ironic - euthanasia is (we would hope) compassionate, whereas capital punishment is not, so therefore they shouldnt necessarily be treated in the same way; you cant generalise the behaviour appropriate to one to the other (if u get what i mean).
not that the behaviour deemed 'appropriate' is necessarily 'right' of course, but thats another debate
marcus