Go back
Who owns Gaza?

Who owns Gaza?

Debates

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22642
Clock
16 Nov 23

I thought it was Israel. So why would Israel have to invade Gaza to take the Natural Gas and Oil?



I know Hamas is supposed to control Gaza, but Israel controls water and electricity in Gaza. Hamas' control seems very limited, so how much control does Hamas have over the natural resources of Gaza?

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669946
Clock
16 Nov 23

@metal-brain said
I thought it was Israel. So why would Israel have to invade Gaza to take the Natural Gas and Oil?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R_ojjTGJz7w

I know Hamas is supposed to control Gaza, but Israel controls water and electricity in Gaza. Hamas' control seems very limited, so how much control does Hamas have over the natural resources of Gaza?
In fact that "Who owns Gaza" is not easy to answer:

Froma a legal point of view it belongs to the Palestine Authority. However since 2007 it belongs de facto to Hamas, which doesn not accept the Authority.

Today it is at least partly occupied by Israeli Forces.

Maybe it should belong to the pople living there. Their will is unclear, but Hamas has won the last elections (or so it is said).

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22642
Clock
16 Nov 23

@Ponderable
Who owns the natural resources like gas and oil?
Is invading Gaza necessary for Israel to get the NG and oil assuming that is what they want?

vivify
rain

Joined
08 Mar 11
Moves
12456
Clock
16 Nov 23

The only answer to the conflict is a one-state solution where Palestinians are guaranteed equal rights with Israelis and a temporary form of affirmative action lasting at least ten years.

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
260878
Clock
16 Nov 23

@metal-brain said
@Ponderable
Who owns the natural resources like gas and oil?
Is invading Gaza necessary for Israel to get the NG and oil assuming that is what they want?
If an area is used as a staging point for attacking another area/country, then the attacking area/people/govt, have given up their rights to be treated as a bonafide independent state. They can be annexed by the defending state, and placed under military rule.

For many decades Gaza has attacked and terrorized Israel. It is easy to demonstrate this to the satisfaction of the UN and international community be reference to the dozens of rocket fire, suicide bombings etc into Jewish civilian territory. They have build underground tunnels for military purposes under civilian areas. The entire place is designed for attacking Israel.

Israel had typicallly been defending
- they built walls
- they installed security cameras
- they set up an iron dome
- they have check points in and out.

This is why you will find that their own Arab and Muslim neighbours are for the most part staying out of this conflict. They are also fed up of low terrorist tactics of the Palestinians, and they are wilfully turning a blind eye but still paying lip service and condemning Israel, but nothing concrete is being done. It is strange how nobody is stopping Israel. They condemn with their mouth, but not with action. Secretly most countries want Hamas and their supporters dead and finished with.

The end game here - Hamas is going to be history. Gaza is going be annexed. How many more are going to die? Who knows. The job must be completed, and Israel knows it cannot stop now.

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22642
Clock
16 Nov 23
1 edit

@rajk999 said
If an area is used as a staging point for attacking another area/country, then the attacking area/people/govt, have given up their rights to be treated as a bonafide independent state. They can be annexed by the defending state, and placed under military rule.

For many decades Gaza has attacked and terrorized Israel. It is easy to demonstrate this to the satisfaction of t ...[text shortened]... more are going to die? Who knows. The job must be completed, and Israel knows it cannot stop now.
Israel terrorized Palestinians first. And if supporting Hamas is so bad then Israel should bomb itself for funding Hamas for so many years. Israel is like Dr. Frankenstein. They created a monster and using it as an excuse to be a bigger monster than what they created.

And if you truly believe in the prophesies you are using as an excuse to steal land from your cousins then you believe this leads to the end times as well. Right?

k
Flexible

The wrong side of 60

Joined
22 Dec 11
Moves
37304
Clock
16 Nov 23

@rajk999 said
If an area is used as a staging point for attacking another area/country, then the attacking area/people/govt, have given up their rights to be treated as a bonafide independent state. They can be annexed by the defending state, and placed under military rule.

For many decades Gaza has attacked and terrorized Israel. It is easy to demonstrate this to the satisfaction of t ...[text shortened]... more are going to die? Who knows. The job must be completed, and Israel knows it cannot stop now.
Because the big Satan / US has got their back, without the US there would have been no Israel, it would’ve been strangled at birth, it’s just a useful strategic tool for the US nothing more

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22642
Clock
16 Nov 23

@rajk999 said
If an area is used as a staging point for attacking another area/country, then the attacking area/people/govt, have given up their rights to be treated as a bonafide independent state. They can be annexed by the defending state, and placed under military rule.

For many decades Gaza has attacked and terrorized Israel. It is easy to demonstrate this to the satisfaction of t ...[text shortened]... more are going to die? Who knows. The job must be completed, and Israel knows it cannot stop now.
"Israel had typicallly been defending
- they built walls
- they installed security cameras
- they set up an iron dome
- they have check points in and out."

That is called a prison and half of the people in that prison are children.

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
260878
Clock
16 Nov 23
Vote Up
Vote Down

@metal-brain said
Israel terrorized Palestinians first. And if supporting Hamas is so bad then Israel should bomb itself for funding Hamas for so many years. Israel is like Dr. Frankenstein. They created a monster and using it as an excuse to be a bigger monster than what they created.

And if you truly believe in the prophesies you are using as an excuse to steal land from your cousins then you believe this leads to the end times as well. Right?
Makes no difference. You can create a monster and kill it when it becomes a nuisance. Thats common sense. Why you keep saying that really shows how you lack understanding.

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
260878
Clock
16 Nov 23
Vote Up
Vote Down

@metal-brain said
"Israel had typicallly been defending
- they built walls
- they installed security cameras
- they set up an iron dome
- they have check points in and out."

That is called a prison and half of the people in that prison are children.
Thats where they belong. Nothing can be done. I already posted how many unbiased international observers have shown that these children are damaged goods.

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
260878
Clock
16 Nov 23

@kevcvs57 said
Because the big Satan / US has got their back, without the US there would have been no Israel, it would’ve been strangled at birth, it’s just a useful strategic tool for the US nothing more
Who cares. Israel is still there and prospering. Palestinians are a dying breed. Your desire for Israel to be strangled shows you are on the wrong side of history and destined for failure like the rest of the world who hate Israel.

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669946
Clock
16 Nov 23

@metal-brain said
@Ponderable
Who owns the natural resources like gas and oil?
Is invading Gaza necessary for Israel to get the NG and oil assuming that is what they want?
The ressources are surely not an incentive. Or do you think Hamas planned their terrorist attack to secure their ressources?

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89778
Clock
16 Nov 23
Vote Up
Vote Down

@rajk999 said
Makes no difference. You can create a monster and kill it when it becomes a nuisance. Thats common sense. Why you keep saying that really shows how you lack understanding.
Really now…

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
260878
Clock
16 Nov 23
Vote Up
Vote Down

@shavixmir said
Really now…
Or course. A created monster can be destroyed. Happens all the time. The US and Taliban is another example. Created by the USA because of some need, then they turned into a monster and had to be put down.

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22642
Clock
16 Nov 23
Vote Up
Vote Down

@rajk999 said
Makes no difference. You can create a monster and kill it when it becomes a nuisance. Thats common sense. Why you keep saying that really shows how you lack understanding.
If you truly believe in the prophesies you are using as an excuse to steal land from your cousins then you believe this leads to the end times as well. Right?

What makes you think you will live through the end times?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.