Go back
Why the

Why the "long covid" narrative is BS

Debates


@shavixmir said
This isn’t true.
The amount of patients in many countries were nearly overwhelming the health services.

The reason it didn’t happen, is because meaures were taken.
Possibly in the Spring of 2020. But now? Not a chance.


@sh76 said
I don't think what China is doing is about naked fear.

It's about justifying its zero-covid policy. New Zealand and Australia can say "oh well, we tried zero-covid, but it's time to give up on that; at least we have vaccines now." China can't. China boasted to the world (and it's own people) that its authoritarianism gave it the power to live without covid unlike those mewlin ...[text shortened]... and acknowledge the realize that you cannot forever stamp out a super-contagious respiratory virus.
unlike those mewling democratic governments whose people have no willpower.

I understand your point, China is clearly going too far with its lockdowns, but despite the earlier severity of COVID, our mewling democratic government (despite its flaws) has done a reasonably good job balancing restrictions with giving its citizens some freedoms to make their own choices.


@sh76 said
Sorry for the click-baity title, but this is aggravating me.

Okay, to start: Yes, long covid happens. So does long flu and long pneumonia and long a lot of other things.

I've seen assertions that long covid affects between 10 and 30% of infected people. I know that's a wide range, but it's impossible to get a better number as far as I can tell (https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...[text shortened]... hat China is doing and against any business/school closure and child masking movements still around.
Were any of these people you know that had long covid vaccinated with covid gene vaccines? If so, before or after getting covid?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@metal-brain said
Were any of these people you know that had long covid vaccinated with covid gene vaccines? If so, before or after getting covid?
The two people that were hospitalized in 2020 obviously had covid before the vaccines. I assume both were vaxxed later, though I'm not sure.

The two people with the minor smell/taste issues were both vaxxed and both had very mild covid cases with lingering smell/taste issues.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@mchill said
unlike those mewling democratic governments whose people have no willpower.

I understand your point, China is clearly going too far with its lockdowns, but despite the earlier severity of COVID, our mewling democratic government (despite its flaws) has done a reasonably good job balancing restrictions with giving its citizens some freedoms to make their own choices.
The federal government, perhaps. But many states made stupid mistakes, including and especially closing schools, masking little children, closing parks, filling in skate parks (that was a good one), closing hiking trails and tennis courts.

None are tragedies (except closing schools), but pretty dumb.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sh76 said
Possibly in the Spring of 2020. But now? Not a chance.
There are no more measures at the moment.


@sh76 said
I can't find it now, but a blue checkmark Tweeted the other day that society was doomed to have to deal with covid disability as its dominant issue for the foreseeable future because 10-30% of cases get long covid and long covid can be disabling.

While not as direct, major media pieces have picked up this sentiment. It's fallacious. That's my point.

Restrict long covid suf ...[text shortened]... . But the I see it used it more "mandate masks in schools" or "mandate boosters" because long covid.
While not as direct, major media pieces have picked up this sentiment. It's fallacious. That's my point.

You're stuck in your own fallacious argument here. When you point to an extreme example of a twitterer making a provocative statement (which is wat twitterers do) and equating it to major media doing it "not as direct" it seems like you're admitting the media are making more reasoned statements on the issue (and we don't have any examples).

Generally this idea that you've got a finger on the "narrative" here based on a few tweets is itself fallacious. We're going to be deconstructing this crisis, what went wrong and right etc, over and over for decades. Some takes will be bad.

1 edit

@sh76 said
Sorry for the click-baity title, but this is aggravating me.

Okay, to start: Yes, long covid happens. So does long flu and long pneumonia and long a lot of other things.

I've seen assertions that long covid affects between 10 and 30% of infected people. I know that's a wide range, but it's impossible to get a better number as far as I can tell (https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...[text shortened]... hat China is doing and against any business/school closure and child masking movements still around.
Some rational points here but you end the post by “lumping’ mask mandates at work and school closures in with what China is doing in places like Shanghai and other places, I guess there’s a lot of this ‘lumping’ thing going on. But your right we should stop it.


@sh76 said
The two people that were hospitalized in 2020 obviously had covid before the vaccines. I assume both were vaxxed later, though I'm not sure.

The two people with the minor smell/taste issues were both vaxxed and both had very mild covid cases with lingering smell/taste issues.
My brother was hospitalized with covid over 1 year ago. He recovered and after he got out of the hospital they gave him the Moderna gene vaccine shots. He said that made him worse and swore it was the vaccines that made his health slowly deteriorate.

My brother died a few weeks ago, over 1 year after he got out of the hospital. My brother was diabetic and at high risk so the case could be made that he should have taken the vaccine to possibly prevent him getting hospitalized, but because he took the jabs after he got covid it is impossible to know. My brother swore it was the vaccine that was killing him. I am taking his word for it.

If someone recovers from covid please discourage them from getting the gene vaccines. You do not want what happened to my brother happen to those you care about. It will damage their immune system, weaken them even more and they could get Peripheral Neuropathy and die. It will seem like ALS.

https://www.shtfplan.com/headline-news/pfizer-documents-modernas-covid-19-vaxx-can-damage-the-immune-system


Here's another good one.

https://twitter.com/drericding/status/1519511820792442880?s=10&t=Z5xfD0Y95Fq5_mykHvfBNQ

Shall we play "spot the sophistry"?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@shavixmir said
There are no more measures at the moment.
There are some left.

https://travel.gc.ca/travel-covid/travel-restrictions/covid-vaccinated-travellers-entering-canada

https://www.nytimes.com/live/2022/04/07/world/covid-19-mandates-cases-vaccine

https://www.nytimes.com/article/nyc-mask-mandate-rules.html

https://abc7ny.com/mask-mandate-kids-under-five-lawsuit-new-york-city/11700644/


@metal-brain said
My brother was hospitalized with covid over 1 year ago. He recovered and after he got out of the hospital they gave him the Moderna gene vaccine shots. He said that made him worse and swore it was the vaccines that made his health slowly deteriorate.

My brother died a few weeks ago, over 1 year after he got out of the hospital. My brother was diabetic and at high risk ...[text shortened]... /www.shtfplan.com/headline-news/pfizer-documents-modernas-covid-19-vaxx-can-damage-the-immune-system
I am sorry for your loss.