Lets be clear here. Russ's 'hard line' was in regard to members posting private and personal info about other members in RHP forums.
Nothing more. If the mods can't take a bit of liquorice, and especially so when they throw their toys around then perhaps they shouldn't be mods. Phlab is a classic example of this. He thinks he can run with the hare's and hunt with the hounds.
A lot of us are very uncomfortable with him being in that position. That was the intent of my post.
skeeter
Originally posted by skeeterI can understand how you may take that viewpoint if you are a hare. . . . .or a hound, whatever one of the two you personally asign yourself.
Lets be clear here. Russ's 'hard line' was in regard to members posting private and personal info about other members in RHP forums.
Nothing more. If the mods can't take a bit of liquorice, and especially so when they throw their toys around then perhaps they shouldn't be mods. Phlab is a classic example of this. He thinks he can run with the hare's and h ...[text shortened]... uncomfortable with him being in that position. That was the intent of my post.
skeeter
As a Bear (?) i think you's did as much to put him on the spot as yous could. Yous attacked his clan specifically, and i now believe that you either want his clan disbanded, or him to lose his place as a Mod. . .am i picking you up right ?
Originally posted by huckleberryhoundNo you're not. I dont hold any ambition of seeing the BFCC disbanded - what I would like to see happen is that either the Phlab is a member of that clan or a member of the RHP moderation team.
I can understand how you may take that viewpoint if you are a hare. . . . .or a hound, whatever one of the two you personally asign yourself.
As a Bear (?) i think you's did as much to put him on the spot as yous could. Yous attacked his clan specifically, and i now believe that you either want his clan disbanded, or him to lose his place as a Mod. . .am i picking you up right ?
In my opinion he cannot do both effectively or with credibility.
Thats all.
skeeter
1 edit
Originally posted by skeeterAnd as he is the clan leader, he would have to leave his own clan. . . which pretty much means disbandment in my book.
No you're not. I dont hold any ambition of seeing the BFCC disbanded - what I would like to see happen is that either the Phlab is a member of that clan or a member of the RHP moderation team.
In my opinion he cannot do both effectively or with credibility.
Thats all.
skeeter
You have a clan dedicated to hating the BFCC/PFC/SSS/the clan formally known as PFC, and the same group of people have spent the last . . . so long, flooding the forums with hate of sorts.
Is this what it was all about ? The rec thing, the crusades, the flooding the clan forum, is it Phlabs you really hate ?
Originally posted by skeeterbeing a clan leader yourself - you are unlikely to see this clearly.
No you're not. I dont hold any ambition of seeing the BFCC disbanded - what I would like to see happen is that either the Phlab is a member of that clan or a member of the RHP moderation team.
In my opinion he cannot do both effectively or with credibility.
Thats all.
skeeter
your clear ambition and devotion to "Raiders of the Lost Carp" obviously blinds you.
starValleyWy would be proud.
Originally posted by huckleberryhoundNot at all. There is precedent for clan leaders handing the reins over and leaving. ROTLC are not dedicated to hating anyone. We were established to suppoft TSM and MOTSM clans in neutralising the imbalance that the likes of the BFCC held over the rec system and, perhaps more importantly, the RHP forums.
And as he is the clan leader, he would have to leave his own clan. . . which pretty much means disbandment in my book.
You have a clan dedicated to hating the BFCC/PFC/SSS/the clan formally known as PFC, and the same group of people have spent the last . . . so long, flooding the forums with hate of sorts.
Is this what it was all about ? The rec thing, the crusades, the flooding the clan forum, is it Phlabs you really hate ?
The Phlab? I have a soft spot for him but his actions lately, have clearly taken him beyond the pale. Mod or BFCC - that's his choices.
skeeter
1 edit
Originally posted by skeeterSo one final question, and i'll be happy. . .If Phlabbs wasn't in the PFC/BFFC/SSS/PISSFLAPS, would you have attacked the rec system the way yous did ?
Not at all. There is precedent for clan leaders handing the reins over and leaving. ROTLC are not dedicated to hating anyone. We were established to suppoft TSM and MOTSM clans in neutralising the imbalance that the likes of the BFCC held over the rec system and, perhaps more importantly, the RHP forums.
The Phlab? I have a soft spot for him but his acti ...[text shortened]... ns lately, have clearly taken him beyond the pale. Mod or BFCC - that's his choices.
skeeter
Originally posted by huckleberryhound".......and you were doing so well agent Starling..."
So one final question, and i'll be happy. . .If Phlabbs wasn't in the PFC/BFFC/SSS/PISSFLAPS, would you have attacked the rec system the way yous did ?
Nice try Huck. Bit like asking someone "....so just when did you decide to stop beating up your wife?"
We didn't attack the rec system, we simply championed to have it more transparent and therefore less open to manipulation. Thats why the BFCC are so filthy on this.
They lost the control. Phlab or no Phlab, it was not a factor. The fact that he put himself in harms way is significant and goes directly to his ability to sustain some degree of impartiality. That is at the hub of all of this.
skeeter
Originally posted by skeeterNice one.
".......and you were doing so well agent Starling..."
Nice try Huck. Bit like asking someone "....so just when did you decide to stop beating up your wife?"
We didn't attack the rec system, we simply championed to have it more transparent and therefore less open to manipulation. Thats why the BFCC are so filthy on this.
They lost the control. Phl ...[text shortened]... lity to sustain some degree of impartiality. That is at the hub of all of this.
skeeter