Go back
misuse of vacation sign

misuse of vacation sign

General

d
His Mateship

Glowing in the dark

Joined
30 Apr 05
Moves
118683
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I have played a number of players recently who continue to play (often for days on end) while displaying a vacation symbol ......... using the sign to avoid making moves in some games?

This is an area on this excellent site that needs tightening

D

Brisbane, Australia

Joined
08 Sep 03
Moves
17480
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by drdon
I have played a number of players recently who continue to play (often for days on end) while displaying a vacation symbol ......... using the sign to avoid making moves in some games?

This is an area on this excellent site that needs tightening
No...I have my vacation sign up, because I can do my thing without having to stop making moves, but I won't be making as many.

phil nutley
Quantum Theorist

Cuckoo land

Joined
19 Feb 02
Moves
83167
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by drdon
I have played a number of players recently who continue to play (often for days on end) while displaying a vacation symbol ......... using the sign to avoid making moves in some games?

This is an area on this excellent site that needs tightening
Why
If you see they are moving, but dont move in your game, time em out.

No guilt.

d
His Mateship

Glowing in the dark

Joined
30 Apr 05
Moves
118683
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I don't like timing players out who are on vacation. Why have the sign if it is open to such abuse? Do I have to check each players move history to check if they are fudging?

d
His Mateship

Glowing in the dark

Joined
30 Apr 05
Moves
118683
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

This is exactly the sort of misuse I'm talking about.

D

Brisbane, Australia

Joined
08 Sep 03
Moves
17480
Clock
13 Jul 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by drdon
I don't like timing players out who are on vacation. Why have the sign if it is open to such abuse? Do I have to check each players move history to check if they are fudging?
Just click their name in the "My Games" section, and check their "Last Moved" time. If they aren't moving in your game, TO. And what abuse do you mean? My abuse?

I ARE PANT!

d
His Mateship

Glowing in the dark

Joined
30 Apr 05
Moves
118683
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sure, but why just restrict the use of the sign? Checking the last moved of each player seems a round about way to do it

phil nutley
Quantum Theorist

Cuckoo land

Joined
19 Feb 02
Moves
83167
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by drdon
Sure, but why just restrict the use of the sign? Checking the last moved of each player seems a round about way to do it
So what do you suggest. People will always miss use rules to suit their own end.
If you want to put more controls in it becomes like big brother and we will have to apply to Russ for time of.
Use yr noddle! If they are moveing, time em out. If they aint then they probably are on holiday and give em the benifit of the doubt.

d
His Mateship

Glowing in the dark

Joined
30 Apr 05
Moves
118683
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by phil nutley
So what do you suggest. People will always miss use rules to suit their own end.
If you want to put more controls in it becomes like big brother and we will have to apply to Russ for time of.
Use yr noddle! If they are moveing, time em out. If they aint then they probably are on holiday and give em the benifit of the doubt.
So what's the use of a symbol that does not mean what is says? If what you say is true, a clean shave with Ocham razor is needed- if it is so clearly open to abuse, tighten it up or chuck it out

C
Not Aleister

Control room

Joined
17 Apr 02
Moves
91813
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Because all it is, is an indication that the player is / might be on vacation etc.
Nothing more.
It's not something you or your opponent needs to honor.

It's just information.

m

Joined
11 Aug 03
Moves
41129
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Usually reading the vacation message clears up the problem. I often put up my flag when I'm visiting my parents saying that I'll try to move but I don't have the same access to a computer so it won't be as much as usual. Most people would try and move if they could, if only because they are not guaranteed that they won't be timed out regardless of the flag.

- Mike

f
Diane

Nairn

Joined
23 Feb 04
Moves
90933
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by drdon
I have played a number of players recently who continue to play (often for days on end) while displaying a vacation symbol ......... using the sign to avoid making moves in some games?

This is an area on this excellent site that needs tightening
nope...seems perfectly adequate to me.... think you just got out of the wrong side of bed and needed to moan...Lots of players play with their vacation sign up.... have you never done it? and if you are waiting for players to move then go ask for a challenge while you wait,there is always someone willing to have a game of lovely lovely chess!!

Diane

E
Damn fine Clan!

The Double R Diner

Joined
03 Sep 03
Moves
72459
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by drdon
I have played a number of players recently who continue to play (often for days on end) while displaying a vacation symbol ......... using the sign to avoid making moves in some games?

This is an area on this excellent site that needs tightening
If I was King of RHP I would do away with the vacation flag and make all games auto-timeout, that would lay it on the line and people would then learn to manage their time controls correctly.

N
The eyes of truth

elsewhere

Joined
26 Apr 04
Moves
21784
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Exy
If I was King of RHP I would do away with the vacation flag and make [b]all games auto-timeout, that would lay it on the line and people would then learn to manage their time controls correctly.[/b]
How about an allotted amount of vacation days per year? Like two weeks for emergencies in hich all your games freeze. Once you use them their gone. And if you move while on vacation it cancels out your away setting.

E
Damn fine Clan!

The Double R Diner

Joined
03 Sep 03
Moves
72459
Clock
13 Jul 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nyxie
How about an allotted amount of vacation days per year? Like two weeks for emergencies in hich all your games freeze. Once you use them their gone. And if you move while on vacation it cancels out your away setting.
The problem with that is that someone could put their vacation flag on and then leave the site and hold up countless games.

My method is better and puts the onus on people to be more responsible about their time management.

It would also be less work for Russ to implement.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.