19 Sep 15
Originally posted by Bobla45All 3 accounts paid money, so it's all good. 😛
Between the dates of 11 & 12 March of this year, in a time period of a little over 20 hours, 3 long term players, Luck, sagator, and Tukumnieks, flat out stopped moving. In a little over 20 hours. Between the 3 of them, they had made 2,079,843 moves. What are the odds of that?
19 Sep 15
Originally posted by Bobla45Are you implying that they are the same person?
Between the dates of 11 & 12 March of this year, in a time period of a little over 20 hours, 3 long term players, Luck, sagator, and Tukumnieks, flat out stopped moving. In a little over 20 hours. Between the 3 of them, they had made 2,079,843 moves. What are the odds of that?
- Joined
- 20 Oct 02
- Moves
- 599502
19 Sep 15
Originally posted by divegeesterI'm not sure if I am implying it or not. That may sound like a cop out, but I would be lying if I didnt say that it did cross my mind. I have played Harri (Luck) numerous times over the years, and Tukumnieks a few times, although I cant remember chatting with him. Harri had a relative that that announced he had suffered a stroke and that he would be back when he was fit. I did find that a little odd. In the end, I think I just find it to be an incredible coincidence. If you were to go to the MAP page, find any 3 black stars that total approximately 2 million moves and watch them all stop moving within the next 20 hours, never to move again. I find the odds of that happening fairly incredible.
Are you implying that they are the same person?
- Joined
- 20 Oct 02
- Moves
- 599502
19 Sep 15
Originally posted by coquetteI won't pretend I really know what that means, I googled it and I think you are trying to tell me I am overthinking the situation. Maybe. But if you, Mctayto, and snjortp, who between the 3 of you have approximately 21 years of play on RHP, and of the hundreds of thousands of people who have passed through this site over the years are 4th, 5th, and 6th on a list of the all time movers were to all suddenly stop moving within the next 20 hours, I have to say that is quite a coincidence. And no, I don't think you are all the same person, but what are the odds of something like that happening?
walks like a duck, talks like a duck, it's obviously a cow.
19 Sep 15
Originally posted by Bobla45It's probably a coincidence. I say this because there are probably enough active members for three of anything similar to occur. And I'm saying 'probably' because...
Between the dates of 11 & 12 March of this year, in a time period of a little over 20 hours, 3 long term players, Luck, sagator, and Tukumnieks, flat out stopped moving. In a little over 20 hours. Between the 3 of them, they had made 2,079,843 moves. What are the odds of that?
1. I don't know how many active members there are, but I'm guessing it's a large enough number for this to happen.
2. It's only a gut feeling, and not based on any sort of statistical analysis... but it's probably right.
- Joined
- 20 Oct 02
- Moves
- 599502
19 Sep 15
Originally posted by lemon limeI like #2....I wish there was a statistician on site, I think what interests me the most is what the odds would be of this occurring.
It's probably a coincidence. I say this because there are probably enough active members for three of anything similar to occur. And I'm saying 'probably' because...
1. I don't know how many active members there are, but I'm guessing it's a large enough number for this to happen.
2. It's only a gut feeling, and not based on any sort of statistical analysis... but it's probably right.
Originally posted by Bobla45@Luck "Last moved 191 days 5 hours and 20 minutes ago" | 'All Moves 808611"
Between the dates of 11 & 12 March of this year, in a time period of a little over 20 hours, 3 long term players, Luck, sagator, and Tukumnieks, flat out stopped moving. In a little over 20 hours. Between the 3 of them, they had made 2,079,843 moves. What are the odds of that?
@sagator "Last moved 191 days 13 hours and 58 minutes ago" | "All Moves 776191"
@Tukumnieks ''Last moved 190 days 17 hours and 45 minutes ago" | "All Moves 495041"
Fascinating thread; the odds at best are probably even less than the proverbial slim to none.
Thanks, @Bobla45. "All Moves 423612"
- Joined
- 20 Oct 02
- Moves
- 599502
19 Sep 15
Originally posted by Grampy BobbyThanks GB, I remember discussing this with you a few months ago. I am not a statistician, but like lemonlime said, this is just a "gut" thing. My god, what are the odds? Hundreds and hundreds of thousands of people have passed through this site since 2001, and 3 top 20 players all shut it down in a 20 hour time frame. I think I would have better odds of hitting Powerball than seeing this....
@Luck "Last moved 191 days 5 hours and 20 minutes ago" | 'All Moves 808611"
@sagator "Last moved 191 days 13 hours and 58 minutes ago" | "All Moves 776191"
@Tukumnieks ''Last moved 190 days 17 hours and 45 minutes ago" | "All Moves 495041"
Fascinating thread; the odds at best are probably even less than the proverbial slim to none.
Thanks, Bobla45.
Originally posted by Bobla45Yeah, it occurred to me after getting offline that your own gut feeling about this would carry more weight than mine. I read your message again... you know them, but do the three of them know each other?
I like #2....I wish there was a statistician on site, I think what interests me the most is what the odds would be of this occurring.
19 Sep 15
It is a conicidence. Both Tukumieks and sagators ad their subscription running out and finished their last game (coincidently, since this also depended on their opponenets) at that date, while Harri (Luck) was under full steam and had dozens of active agmes and an active subscription.
The odds are small but well above zero.
Originally posted by Ponderable"The chance of an average person living in the US being struck by lightning in a given year is estimated at 1 in 960,000, while the chance of being struck by lightning in a lifetime is 1 in 12,000 (estimated lifespan of 80 years)..." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lightning_strike
It is a conicidence. Both Tukumieks and sagators ad their subscription running out and finished their last game (coincidently, since this also depended on their opponenets) at that date, while Harri (Luck) was under full steam and had dozens of active agmes and an active subscription.
The odds are small but well above zero.
_______________________________________________
Ponderable, if "the chance of being struck by lightning in a lifetime is 1 in 960,000" what would be the equation
for the odds of three people being struck by lighting within the same twenty four hour period?
____________________
Footnote: Wouldn't the sudden disappearance of three chess players who made a combined total of "2,079,843 moves" during their membership here have caused a considerable negative impact on Red Hot Pawn's total daily chess move activity volume since their disappearance?.