Go back
Can Black survive?

Can Black survive?

Only Chess

T

Joined
29 Jul 01
Moves
60863
Clock
24 Feb 06
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Game 1737288

The above is a recent game I played with chessicle. I - as black - resigned on move 47, facing a seemingly unstoppable pawn barrage, and feeling somewhat livid with not having played Kd6 when I had the chance. The final position (black to play) looks like this:



Looking at it again it's not such an immediate win for white as I had first thought.

What is white's winning line, or can black survive?

z

127.0.0.1

Joined
27 Oct 05
Moves
158564
Clock
24 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by T1000
Game 1737288

The above is a recent game I played with chessicle. I - as black - resigned on move 47, facing a seemingly unstoppable pawn barrage, and feeling somewhat livid with not having played Kd6 when I had the chance. The final position (black to play) looks like this:

[fen]8/p1p5/1PP5/K1P1k1pp/4p3/4N1P1/4b2P/8 b - - 0 47[/fen]

Looking at i white as I had first thought. What is white's winning line? (Black can't survive... can he?)
if cxb6+ then cxb6
if Kd6 then bxa7;
if axb6+, Kxb6 wins (your bishop cant get back and his king holds yours off.
if axb6+ then cxb6;
If then Kd6 then b7
If if cxb6+ Kxb6 is the same as above.

Ragnorak
For RHP addons...

tinyurl.com/yssp6g

Joined
16 Mar 04
Moves
15013
Clock
24 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by zebano
if cxb6+ then cxb6
if Kd6 then bxa7;
if axb6+, Kxb6 wins (your bishop cant get back and his king holds yours off.
if axb6+ then cxb6;
If then Kd6 then b7
If if cxb6+ Kxb6 is the same as above.
I think it could go down to zugzwang after saccing your bishop for his passed pawn, but I'm not sure.

I don't understand your notation, but if I'm understanding correctly, its wrong.

D

Ragnorak
For RHP addons...

tinyurl.com/yssp6g

Joined
16 Mar 04
Moves
15013
Clock
24 Feb 06
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

47...axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6 49. Kxb6 Kd6 is forced, imo.

[Edit]Then 50. Nf5+ wins.

This was my analysis before I found the Nf5+ move.
"
Then 50. c7 Ba6 offering to sac the bishop for the crucial passed pawn, and forcing the white king to the edge, allowing the black king to reach the centre of the board first.

If the bishop gets to c8, its a touch position to break down, so i think I'd take the bishop, but then it gets really complicated. More calculation required."

D

T

Joined
29 Jul 01
Moves
60863
Clock
24 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by zebano
if cxb6+ then cxb6
if Kd6 then bxa7;
if axb6+, Kxb6 wins (your bishop cant get back and his king holds yours off.
After 47. ... axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6+ 49. Kxb6 black has the following: 49. ... Ke6 50. c7 Kd7 and then what is white's best move? Black's bishop can land on a6 and be protected tactically (since Kxa6 gives black Kxc7).

T

Joined
29 Jul 01
Moves
60863
Clock
24 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ragnorak
47...axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6 49. Kxb6 Kd6 is forced, imo.

Then 50. Ba6 offering to sac the bishop for the crucial passed pawn, and forcing the white king to the edge, allowing the black king to reach the centre of the board first.

If the bishop gets to c8, its a touch position to break down, so i think I'd take the bishop, but then it gets really complicated. More calculation required.

D
Aye, that's kind of where I'm heading, though 49. ... Ke6 is (I think, maybe) better for black than 49. ... Kd6.

Ragnorak
For RHP addons...

tinyurl.com/yssp6g

Joined
16 Mar 04
Moves
15013
Clock
24 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by T1000
Aye, that's kind of where I'm heading, though 49. ... Ke6 is (I think, maybe) better for black than 49. ... Kd6.
Even after 49...Ke6 (which probably is a better move than Kd6) 50. Nf5+ wins. (See edit above)

D

T

Joined
29 Jul 01
Moves
60863
Clock
24 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ragnorak
Even after 49...Ke6 (which probably is a better move than Kd6) 50. Nf5+ wins. (See edit above)

D
51. ... Bc4 maybe in response to 50. Nf5+

Edit: Scrub that. The knight is still too active - so that even if the c pawn is stopped the knight will start mopping up the pawns. Does look like a definite loss for black.

Ragnorak
For RHP addons...

tinyurl.com/yssp6g

Joined
16 Mar 04
Moves
15013
Clock
24 Feb 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by T1000
51. ... Bc4 maybe in response to 50. Nf5+

Edit: Scrub that. The knight is still too active - so that even if the c pawn is stopped the knight will start mopping up the pawns. Does look like a definite loss for black.
The knight isn't really active as he is too concerned with the passed e pawn. If he goes after the others, white is lost.

I think the key move comes after 47...axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6 49. Kxb6 Ke6

So 50. c7 Kd7 51. Nd5 should do the job, I think (again 🙄)

Certainly a very complicated and interesting position. And well worth playing on in.

D

T

Joined
29 Jul 01
Moves
60863
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ragnorak
The knight isn't really active as he is too concerned with the passed e pawn. If he goes after the others, white is lost.

I think the key move comes after 47...axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6 49. Kxb6 Ke6

So 50. c7 Kd7 51. Nd5 should do the job, I think (again 🙄)

Certainly a very complicated and interesting position. And well worth playing on in.

D
Sorry - I should have been more clear - the line I was looking at when I said the knight was active was: 47...axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6 49. Kxb6 Ke6 50. Nf5 Bc4 51. c7 Kd7 52. Nd6 Ba6 53. Kxa6 Kxc7 and then the knight romps away with it 54. Nxe4 g4 55. Nf6 h4. 56. gxh4 Kd6 57. Nxg4 winning easily.

But I think you're right, 47...axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6 49. Kxb6 Ke6 50. c7 Kd7 51. Nd5 looks like it wins more quickly (since after 51. ... Bg5 white has 52. Nf6+ forking the king and the passed e pawn).

Thanks Rag for taking a look and for your analysis - much appreciated.

T

Somewhere out there!

Joined
09 Nov 04
Moves
2700
Clock
24 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ragnorak
The knight isn't really active as he is too concerned with the passed e pawn. If he goes after the others, white is lost.

I think the key move comes after 47...axb6 48. cxb6 cxb6 49. Kxb6 Ke6

So 50. c7 Kd7 51. Nd5 should do the job, I think (again 🙄)

Certainly a very complicated and interesting position. And well worth playing on in.

D
I think it is game over for black, after Nd5 he has no decent way to prevent queening, the toughest defence seems Bg4 which is followed by Nf6+ Nxe4 and Nxg5 where it is really hopeless for black.

T
Full speed locomotiv

On tracks.

Joined
03 Oct 04
Moves
12831
Clock
25 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by T1000
Game 1737288

The above is a recent game I played with chessicle. I - as black - resigned on move 47, facing a seemingly unstoppable pawn barrage, and feeling somewhat livid with not having played Kd6 when I had the chance. The final position (black to play) looks like this:

[fen]8/p1p5/1PP5/K1P1k1pp/4p3/4N1P1/4b2P/8 b - - 0 47[/fen]

Looking at i ...[text shortened]... win for white as I had first thought.

What is white's winning line, or can black survive?
I dont understand the resigning. Why? You had nothing to lose to continue in spite of the pawn advance. If you took a little more time you would of seen KD6. People are always in a rush to resign for some strange reason.

K
Mel Kirwan

Hauxton

Joined
20 Nov 05
Moves
17764
Clock
25 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Testrider
I think it is game over for black, after Nd5 he has no decent way to prevent queening, the toughest defence seems Bg4 which is followed by Nf6+ Nxe4 and Nxg5 where it is really hopeless for black.
It's a clear win for white.

K
Mel Kirwan

Hauxton

Joined
20 Nov 05
Moves
17764
Clock
25 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Kirwan
It's a clear win for white.
I think you started to go wrong on move 43.......Be2. Great game though!

Ragnorak
For RHP addons...

tinyurl.com/yssp6g

Joined
16 Mar 04
Moves
15013
Clock
25 Feb 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Trains44
I dont understand the resigning. Why? You had nothing to lose to continue in spite of the pawn advance. If you took a little more time you would of seen KD6. People are always in a rush to resign for some strange reason.
Kd6? Its illegal to move into check.

D

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.