Originally posted by sonhouse
Can anyone here run a reality check on this game: 11220362 between #1 and #2 here. Or just play it over and see if it seems like a game between humans?
Sonhouse,
I looked it over. I'm not overly familiar with the Philidor Defense but the game appears to be pretty standard theory through move 10 or so. After that, I get lost in a lot of the moves.
There are some moves that I question, 'what thought process is going on here'. I quickly looked at several moves, say for example move 19. Why not Bxh4. Is the pawn poisoned? A quick look made it look alright and indeed I probably wouldn't have seen the fault in it until I plugged it into my computer and 7 moves later black is very clearly losing the game. Also, move 47, why Rxe5 and not dxe5? I didnt' try to analysis it further. My inclination as a human would have been dxe5 to keep from dropping the c7 pawn.
And then, there are a whole heap of moves that I don't understand at all. This seems clear to me, starting around move 20 or so black falls behind positionally. There are probably 30 or so moves in that game that I would never have considered.
If I find time I'll run the numbers on the game. Too late tonight to attempt this. My human analysis was anything but thorough (sorry). I honestly don't feel like putting a lot of time into a game that was almost certainly a battle between two CPUs.
K.T.