Go back
E4, No longer the best by test?

E4, No longer the best by test?

Only Chess

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by exigentsky
Thanks for all the comments. Now, I definitely will still look into the book once its out. The only thing really scary about 1 e4 is the Sicilian.
It doesn't matter how you open. If you are going to play e4 you have to have a strategy to play against the Sicilian and you are right to be cautious, you just have to be prepared. I would suggest taking the bull by the horns, learning some principals of the Open 'Sicilain and play it. The other white approaches just don't create as many problems for black. You may get your behind kicked a few times, but you'll learn faster. The other thing to remember is that 1.e4 e5 has a ton of theory behind it also and it is easier for black to draw than some of the more unbalanced openings.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Yeah, I'm sure you are right. But, what's a good defense against the Najdorf?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by exigentsky
Yeah, I'm sure you are right. But, what's a good defense against the Najdorf?
Avoid it.

Vote Up
Vote Down

What's the best way to avoid it?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by BLReid
Avoid it.
Well, if you are going to play the Open Sicilian you have to have some preferred line and play it consistently so you get to know it. I don't use 1.e4 very much as I like d4, c4 or Nf3 better, and I haven't played the Sicilian in the last two or three years so I am probably not the best to answer that. I usually play the Pirc, Scandanavian or Berlin Defense to the Ruy against e4. If I was going to go back to the Sicilian I would probably play some combination of the Najorf and Scheveningen looking for an opportunity to play the Hedgehog, so I would have to do some work on that.

Any e4 players out there that have a favorite line against the Najdorf? Something somewhat forcing to minimize black options... Unfortunately the Najdorf is a pretty big animal...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Anyone playing the English Attack, 6.Be3 7.f3...? It should work against the Najdorf, Dragon and Scheveningen and would be a relatively consistent approach?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by exigentsky
What's the best way to avoid it?
play d4😀

Vote Up
Vote Down

Haha, how about with e4?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by MotownDave
Anyone playing the English Attack, 6.Be3 7.f3...? It should work against the Najdorf, Dragon and Scheveningen and would be a relatively consistent approach?
i play that setup against the dragon (the yugoslav attack), but not the others.

is the najdorf really that scary? i haven't had one on this site, but when playing on servers Bc4 lines (sozin) seen pretty effective.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by exigentsky
Haha, how about with e4?
You could try the bb5 line

1. e4 - c5
2. nf3 - d6
3. bb5 -

Vote Up
Vote Down

Yeah, that's a good line, it could take some Najdorf players out of their comfort zone. Though, d4 is unavoidable and it will still transpose into a similar game.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by darkassassin9512
i play that setup against the dragon (the yugoslav attack), but not the others.

is the najdorf really that scary? i haven't had one on this site, but when playing on servers Bc4 lines (sozin) seen pretty effective.
It is a little better against the Dragon because the fianchetto is a target, but it is a menace to the others also. You might want to consider it.

Dave

Vote Up
Vote Down

Thanksfully, it is no threat to the Hyper-Accelerated Dragon. Only the Maroczy could be a difficulty. 🙂

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by LordOfTheChessboard
You could try the bb5 line

1. e4 - c5
2. nf3 - d6
3. bb5 -
The ...Bb5 lines are pretty simple enough to play but not against players who play 2... e6 as their second moves and transpose into other various Sicilian setups.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Oddjob291
The ...Bb5 lines are pretty simple enough to play but not against players who play 2... e6 as their second moves and transpose into other various Sicilian setups.
The only problem I have with the 2. e6 lines is that if my opponent doesn't play Bc4, Bb5 or Bg5 I may want to play e5 in one go.