Originally posted by ih8sens
Aren't you ultimately discussing a game that has already passed? and then coincidentally talking about one in progress at the same time???
If I talked about a famous match on here between two grandmasters, and then a few hours later I end up in the same position, did I cheat?
I think it comes down to motive, and in the example in this thread, there is ...[text shortened]...
Innocent until proven guilty. If there's a question of intent, no one should be banned.
if you talk about the master game first, you're
following that game in your own game. which is perfectly okay.
if you talk about the master game when you've already started a similar game, you're certainly risking it. if you then ask about that game you're clearly violating 3b, outside assistance. same goes to fritzing that master game while you 'happen to be' in an identical position.
you can of course read/follow discussion as much as you can find on the game, but you can't ask about it. neither can you start a discussion about the game, and observe others discussing it, as you'd be clearly fishing.
all this is pretty obvious, and only someone trying to bend the rules would do these things.