Originally posted by vipiu
maybe they should just let all chess players to vote...I have the feeling that a Carlsen system for WCh would get by far most of the votes...
Major good changes in history require sacrifices...may Carlsen be sacrificed for a good cause.
Of course the WC system would win if chess players were voting!!! They all want the opportunity to be world champion after all and anyone could win the ''cup'' with some luck, making the chess players salivate over the possibility of being the next world champion. Do you think it would be fair if Etienne Bacrot won the world championship? Would he really be the best in the world and THE man to beat? Hell no, but he could win it. The title wouldn't mean anything, just bragging rights for a year. The best team in the world is maybe half the time the one who ends up winning the world cup.
At Woodworm: Yes I understand how the champion in the UFC shouldn't be called the ''best in the world''. Other organizations exists in those kinds of
sports. In chess, there is only really FIDE, so the best in FIDE really is the best in the world. There's no problem there.
I'm not saying the current system is perfect and I don't agree with all the advantages the World champion has, but if they could fix that and ease on the hardcorness of the method to pick the challenger, the system would be fine. Taking a system from team sports really is the worst way to go. The only other option would be a scoring system based on tournament performances, like F1 Racing with the world champion being crowned at the end of the year. Advantages would be that great players would be forced to play very frequently and also, the best player in the world should win it almost everytime, while everyone gets a fair shot at the beggining. The disadvantage is the lack of a thrilling single event to watch.
I propose a mixture of the two, where the top scoring player - F1 style -(or the 2nd if the top guy is the champ) at the end of the year is the one who gets to challenge the world champion. That sounds good to me! Nothing too complicated and players don't have to go out of their way in that grueling road to challenge the champ.