Originally posted by Sicilian Smaug
It doesn't work like that though. Say a 1600 player plays ten 1400 players.
He will not win them all, more than likely he will win between 5 and 7 of them, draw 1 or 2, and lose 2 or 3 of them. Net gain - very little,
yeah, 200pts difference still gives pretty tough game. one slip and the game is gone. you have to be very careful against a player rated 200 points lower.
and it's all about being careful. -if you play against weaker players
more careful than people
in general do, you
will gain higher rating for it. of course it can be said that more careful play is stronger, but that doesn't really translate to playing against higher rated opponents, as people already focus more and play with special care against them.
I believe you can get 100-200 extra points playing against low rated opponents, if you just take special care. but it doesn't make the player stronger against his peers or higher. a 1400 drops a piece in almost every game. winning those games against him is not an achievement, but you still get the points for it. a 1200 could've won those just as well. (no, I'm not going to play all you 1200-1400's who now, once again, want to "kick my ass". leave the challenge button be. it was not an insult.)
I'm not worried about facing the guy with the 80% winning ratio, I'm worried about the one with 40% and keeping the same rating. the latter plays only against people that are stronger than him, the former around 250-300 lower rated. at least for me, the 40% guys are a lot harder to handle.