Originally posted by Palynka
Wait, isn't Hawking radiation the main reason why people believe that CERN's black holes will not last more than a few nanoseconds? 😕
You're scaring me.
PS: The difference in yours and FF's statement is that yours states that the particles in the jets are approaching the black hole and his states that they're moving away from it. I always thought it was the latter (like he said), can you clear this up?
"Wait, isn't Hawking radiation the main reason why people believe that CERN's black holes will not last more than a few nanoseconds? 😕"
Well I never heard this explanation before now. I think that a very sensible thing to say is that nano black holes have really tiny even horizons so that the likelihood of something crossing it is zero for all practical purposes.
From what I know Hawking radiation isn't that clearcut to understand and hand waving arguments (if they even can be called that) are made all the time but if one wants to be intellectually honest they are just very poor arguments. And this view of particle pairs being Hawking radiation are everywhere. I think that most people never looked into the equations and just parrot what they heard as an
explanation. It's more or less like the direction of the drain of water in a bathtub. The simple fact is that the Coriolis force doesn't have enough intensity to have any effect on the water's rotation but time and time again you see people saying that.
As for the second question: I think you already linked to this http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/990923a.html Now let's take a look at what they say:
"A fluid falling onto a small object usually cannot fall directly onto it --- most of the matter will miss the object initially, rotate around it, and only gradually be able to hit the central object.
Think of draining your bathtub: Accretion disks are the celestial equivalent of this phenomenon, and can be found around black holes"
What I said (or intended to say) is that you have charged matter falling into the black hole and that causes the jets (which are just radiation). This is just one of the prediction of Maxwell equations: Accelerating charged matter emits radiation. And we have to be clear in the distinction of the falling matter and the emitted radiation (which is just another name for the jets)
I think that you are confusing this phenomenon with the pop science explanation of Hawking radiation but they are two different things.