Originally posted by apathist
[b]Volition.
Violation of what?
Willed decisions are neither inevitable nor random
So what determines a decision if nether emotion nor reasoning nor something random?
If emotion and reasoning (either flawed or sound), and I think our decisions are at least partly determined by our emotions and reasoning, and if there is no truly quantum random element in the brain involved (presumably because there is NO such thing as true quantum randomness), then a decision is determined by emotion and reason alone thus your final decision will be inevitably whatever it will be.
If truly quantum random element in the brain involved (presumably because there IS such thing as true quantum randomness and surely, if so, there must be true quantum randomness in our brain), which final decision made isn't inevitable but truly probabilistic i.e. impossible to predict with absolute certainty EVEN if you had infinite intellect AND magically had an infinite and complete knowledge of all relevant factors.
What is third possibility are you suggesting here other than and contrary to the two possibilities above?
Incidentally; I have no opinion on whether quantum randomness is truly random or merely pseudo-random thus don't know if there is any 'truly' random element, as opposed to mere pseudo-random elements, in our decision making process.