09 Mar '09 06:01>2 edits
From time to time on here, someone will claim that God transcends, and is not bound by, logic. I never know quite what that is supposed to mean (and I’m not sure they do either), but I thought of two possible cases:
The first case would be one in which God simultaneously knows something—call that something Y—and is also totally ignorant of Y.
The second case would be where a sentence like—
“The ambidextrous salad wallows tentatively two-by-four.”
—could actually make sense to God.
[Note that this sentence consists of words that are well-defined within the lexica of the English language, and is also thoroughly grammatical in form. If a person were convinced that it must (somehow) make sense, they might begin to form some weird (cartoonish perhaps) images in their head to support their conviction.]
I was wondering if some of you who are better at logic and reasonable thinking than I am might have some additional examples of what it could mean to say that God is not bound by logic…
The first case would be one in which God simultaneously knows something—call that something Y—and is also totally ignorant of Y.
The second case would be where a sentence like—
“The ambidextrous salad wallows tentatively two-by-four.”
—could actually make sense to God.
[Note that this sentence consists of words that are well-defined within the lexica of the English language, and is also thoroughly grammatical in form. If a person were convinced that it must (somehow) make sense, they might begin to form some weird (cartoonish perhaps) images in their head to support their conviction.]
I was wondering if some of you who are better at logic and reasonable thinking than I am might have some additional examples of what it could mean to say that God is not bound by logic…