Go back
Altruism ~ Nature or Nurture?

Altruism ~ Nature or Nurture?

Spirituality


-Removed-
Surely the post was saved by the deployment of an emoticon?



-Removed-
You know the glib quotation comes from the bible right?

Isn't the bible a good source for deistic altruism?

1 edit



-Removed-
I deny that I look after my son out of selfishness. I do not deny that I look after him out of self interest, but where 'self interest' is 'doing what I want to do'. But to do what I do not want to do would be madness and I would not call that altruism.
A man who looses his wallet that is subsequently picked up and kept by someone else is not being altruistic.


-Removed-
What 'more' are you looking for in 'true altruism'? Must the behaviour be random?

Vote Up
Vote Down

I think you are coming close to the age old problem of free will where people want to put it somewhere in between motivated by prior causes and randomness and are unhappy with either.

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
No problem, I should have given the source with the quote.

For me, 'love and putting others first' is altruism. I wouldn't make it any more complicated than that. People do sometimes act selflessly. - Sure, there are also altruistic acts that are motivated on some level by self interest, but i don't think this is always the case.

I might even claim that animals can be altruistic, but fear I would end up weakening my position. 🙂 (There is youtube footage somewhere of a bird feeding bread to fish with no attempt to catch them).

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ghost of a Duke
I might even claim that animals can be altruistic, but fear I would end up weakening my position. 🙂 (There is youtube footage somewhere of a bird feeding bread to fish with no attempt to catch them).
If parental care is altruism then you won't need to look for inter-species examples.


-Removed-
Suppose someone was in the habit of behaving altruistically, through years of working in a soup kitchen as a volunteer say, so that although the initial motivation may well have been self-serving, the current motivation is just habit.

With regard to the question FMF posed, if a behaviour is possible it's natural. Whether an instance is exhibited by any particular person depends on all sorts of factors.



-Removed-
You seem to be saying that altruism is caring for another without desiring to. Why do you think that is altruism?
If you were forced to care for another would that also be altruism in your book?


If a tax is automatically deducted from your account each month by the government and used for social welfare, and you disagree with said tax (hence no selfishness) are you being altruistic?