Originally posted by robbie carrobie
No is not contradictory at all and your attempts to make it such are nothing short of
a scurrilous distortion of my words. I stated that humans are conscious of the fact
that others suffer pain, I have not stated that animals are conscious of the same
thing, to experience pain and to be conscious of suffering in others are not one and
the sa ...[text shortened]... o one and ripping it
apart and yet it does so, with what appears to me, to be without remorse.
I retract absolutely nothing. Your view, as you have espoused it, is in fact contradictory. You would recognize this and revise your position if you weren't too lazy to bother to educate yourself a bit on this topic.
I stated that humans are conscious of the fact
that others suffer pain, I have not stated that animals are conscious of the same
thing, to experience pain and to be conscious of suffering in others are not one and
the same thing are they, thus your assertions are erroneous and I will be pleased if
you would retract them as they represent a distortion of the reality.
I never claimed that to experience pain and to be conscious of suffering in others are the same thing; and I never claimed that you asserted as much. Learn to frickin read. What I claimed is that pain itself is a conscious state. If an entity is experiencing pain, then it holds conscious states. That's why it is simply blatantly contradictory of you to hold both (1) that consciousness is unique to humans only and (2) that there are non-human animals that experience pain. Do you understand why your position is contradictory now; or should I go it through it yet again for you? A little slower perhaps?
The problem here has nothing to do with conflating experience of pain and the recognition of suffering in another. Nobody here has done that. The problem, again, is that you are too ignorant to understand that pain itself is in fact a conscious state. Your view boils down to the contradictory nonsense that some non-human animals experience pain and yet are not conscious entities.
To be "conscious of" the suffering of another is a higher-order level of mental functioning than just consciousness at its base. An entity can completely lack such capacity and yet still be a conscious entity. Did you miss the part of my post where I mentioned that you would understand that there are different levels and orders of 'consciousness' if you bothered to do any research on this topic?
Again in the hope that you will understand, to experience pain and to be conscious of
suffering in others are not one and the same thing,
Again, in the hope that you will understand, that's not the point. The point is that pain itself is a conscious state. Do you understand this now?