Originally posted by Darfius
Two rocks are concrete. The concept that giving someone something of yours is charity is an illusion in light of pure evolution.
You've simply repeated assertion. I asked 'what gives it
illusory status.' Please explain why you believe this. Here
is my reason for why I think that you are wrong.
Two rocks are concrete, but '2' is not. Two rocks are a representation
of '2.' Thus we can conclude that, while we cannot sense '2,' its
representation gives it reality.
Charity is not concrete, but giving to the poor is a representation of
'charity.' While we cannot sense 'charity,' its representation gives it
reality.
When is charity 'charity?' That is indeed subjective. However, that
'charity' exists at all is not subjective.
Nemesio