14 Sep '11 13:11>
Originally posted by twhiteheadA post scarcity society is by definition space faring, with many many space habitats, so owning the spaceship would be like
And what would you do with your very own spaceship? Travel to your very own planet in your very own solar system in your very own universe?
You only want a space ship because you want the status that goes with it.
[b]My point is that the draconian tyrannical governments needed for communism whilst in an age of scarcity are worse than the ills
of capi ...[text shortened]... most western countries have,
to greater or lesser extents.
I generally agree with that.[/b]
owning a car, or private jet today. It has potential practical value in such a society.
It's communism in that the resources are shared communally, there are no wealthy people who have more resources than
anyone else. The resources are still finite, so there are restrictions on resource use, they are just so generous you never
actually reach them. Note: if you did have some project you wanted to embark on that required more resources than your
personal allotment, you could either gang together with other like minded people to complete the project, or request a share
of the societies governments free production capacity. (presuming here some sort of oversight to make sure your not using
the manufacturies to make an army or terminator robots or similar) There are many options for the politics of such a society,
my personal favourites being variations on democracy.
The production capacity would be (in this system) owned collectively by the people, (also communistic) but automated so
its not run by the people. There are no exploited people, or people who need paying.
Again I recommend looking up so examples in sci-fi literature. The culture being my personal favourite example, but an exact replica
of the culture probably involves a different set of laws of physics. But the basics of the society are real world compatible.
I think post scarcity is a good goal to have as a society, even if it turns out not to be actually possible.
Although I do think it is practically possible to achieve, eventually.
And setting it as a goal helps shape minds into thinking about how we are different and what needs to be done to change that.
the main thing is that when I think, what would a communist civilisation look like, [that has actual people in it, not imaginary
perfect, nice people that don't exist], that would be nice to live in, I always come up with something that looks like a post
scarcity society, or very close to one.
Whether a post scarcity society is possible or not, that fact that the only way I see of making communism work is in such a society,
convinces me that the alternative, in moderation, is the only viable option, until such a society, if ever, is reached.