Spirituality
21 Feb 22
@kellyjay saidBarring scripture, you have no evidence for that position, and scripture is not good evidence.
It isn't other people who called me out by name, and it isn't other people who promised to be with me and never leave me through the good times and the bad. Other people have shared yes, but if God were nothing but a story, what you may claim about Him would be true, but God being real changes everything.
@avalanchethecat saidScriptural support is extraordinary evidence, and lives lived are evidence I've been a Christian for over 40 years now, going through hard times and good ones, and God is faithful. The whole of creation is also evidence; it didn't come from nothing.
Barring scripture, you have no evidence for that position, and scripture is not good evidence.
23 Feb 22
@kellyjay said"Scriptural support is extraordinary evidence..."
Scriptural support is extraordinary evidence, and lives lived are evidence I've been a Christian for over 40 years now, going through hard times and good ones, and God is faithful. The whole of creation is also evidence; it didn't come from nothing.
It really isn't. You might just as well say that the Beowulf was extraordinary evidence for the existence of lake monsters, or that the Odyssey was extraordinary evidence for the existence of cyloptic giants.
@avalanchethecat saidNo scripture is filled with historical, political, poetic, revelation through ~ > 1500 years from ~40 authors from all walks of life. 65 of the books have connection to the same God, and the only one that doesn’t mention Him is filled with His handy work. So the Bible is not like any other book in its writings from all single source books.
"Scriptural support is extraordinary evidence..."
It really isn't. You might just as well say that the Beowulf was extraordinary evidence for the existence of lake monsters, or that the Odyssey was extraordinary evidence for the existence of cyloptic giants.
@avalanchethecat saidIf we were to loose the Bible it would be rebuilt from everything surrounding it. Even leaving out modern sources. Human experience is either considered valid or no, Biblical text rests on that.
"Scriptural support is extraordinary evidence..."
It really isn't. You might just as well say that the Beowulf was extraordinary evidence for the existence of lake monsters, or that the Odyssey was extraordinary evidence for the existence of cyloptic giants.
23 Feb 22
@kellyjay saidThe bible is no different from any other collection of religious texts. Why don't you regard the Vedas in the same reverent manner? A collection of ancient scripture packed full of historical, political, poetic and revelationay detail. In many ways more interesting than your own scripture.
No scripture is filled with historical, political, poetic, revelation through ~ > 1500 years from ~40 authors from all walks of life. 65 of the books have connection to the same God, and the only one that doesn’t mention Him is filled with His handy work. So the Bible is not like any other book in its writings from all single source books.
@kellyjay saidI'm not sure I understand what you are saying here. Do you think the bible could be reassembled if all the stories in it were lost from human knowledge? That's a crazy claim.
If we were to loose the Bible it would be rebuilt from everything surrounding it. Even leaving out modern sources. Human experience is either considered valid or no, Biblical text rests on that.
@avalanchethecat saidHe believes God is real and would make sure the Biblical knowledge gets restored.
I'm not sure I understand what you are saying here. Do you think the bible could be reassembled if all the stories in it were lost from human knowledge? That's a crazy claim.
@avalanchethecat saidAnd older.
The bible is no different from any other collection of religious texts. Why don't you regard the Vedas in the same reverent manner? A collection of ancient scripture packed full of historical, political, poetic and revelationay detail. In many ways more interesting than your own scripture.
@avalanchethecat saidMake a case for it.
The bible is no different from any other collection of religious texts. Why don't you regard the Vedas in the same reverent manner? A collection of ancient scripture packed full of historical, political, poetic and revelationay detail. In many ways more interesting than your own scripture.
@vivify saidWhat we would need to understand God and ourselves going forward. If it required history to be restored yes. It was a hypothetical we can say whatever we want.
He believes God is real and would make sure the Biblical knowledge gets restored.
@avalanchethecat saidI am saying that God would not be limited to reproducing the Bible as it was but could give us what we needed
I'm not sure I understand what you are saying here. Do you think the bible could be reassembled if all the stories in it were lost from human knowledge? That's a crazy claim.
@ghost-of-a-duke saidNot at all facts don’t change just opinions. If there is a discrepancy I will go with the Bible. If the Bible is true there are many “so called facts” that suddenly are not.
You doubt something that's factually true?