Originally posted by twhiteheadthats my point
If you are referring to a Biological relationship then clearly not. If you are using the word father to mean something else then please define it or we cant answer the question (except by realizing that as God does not exist he could not have a father)
Originally posted by twhiteheadThat's fallacious logic. E.g.:
(except by realizing that as God does not exist he could not have a father)
Q: "Did Frodo Baggins have a father?"
A: "Since Frodo Baggins never existed, he doesn't have a father".
The question is whether the concept of "God" is incompatible with the concept of "having a father".
Originally posted by lucifershammerNot as fallacious as you claim. Frodo Baggins does not have a father in the sense that no father of Frodo Baggins has ever existed.
That's fallacious logic. E.g.:
Q: "Did Frodo Baggins have a father?"
A: "Since Frodo Baggins never existed, he doesn't have a father".
The question is whether the concept of "God" is incompatible with the concept of "having a father".
The question "does God have a father" presumes the existence of God.
However, there is absolutely no point in discussing whether the concept of "God" is incompatible with the concept of "having a father" as neither concept is well defined enough to make conclusions about their compatibility.