Go back
can god have a father?

can god have a father?

Spirituality

h

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
1772
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

A
Checkmate 2 U!

Checkmating you!

Joined
16 Dec 06
Moves
42778
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Since there is no post here, I'll answer the title: No (unless you're talking about God the Son, who's father is God the Father. God the Father cannot have an ol' man.)

twhitehead

Cape Town

Joined
14 Apr 05
Moves
52945
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hakaman
If you are referring to a Biological relationship then clearly not. If you are using the word father to mean something else then please define it or we cant answer the question (except by realizing that as God does not exist he could not have a father)

h

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
1772
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
If you are referring to a Biological relationship then clearly not. If you are using the word father to mean something else then please define it or we cant answer the question (except by realizing that as God does not exist he could not have a father)
thats my point

G

Joined
20 Jan 07
Moves
1005
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acemaster
Since there is no post here, I'll answer the title: No (unless you're talking about God the Son, who's father is God the Father. God the Father cannot have an ol' man.)
He can have a son but not a father. Makes sense.

A
Checkmate 2 U!

Checkmating you!

Joined
16 Dec 06
Moves
42778
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by GinoJ
He can have a son but not a father. Makes sense.
God's a supernatural being. He doesn't need a father. Jesus is his son in spirit, even though God didn't have sex with Mary to concieve a baby.

h

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
1772
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acemaster
God's a supernatural being. He doesn't need a father. Jesus is his son in spirit, even though God didn't have sex with Mary to concieve a baby.
but does he want a father,

A
Checkmate 2 U!

Checkmating you!

Joined
16 Dec 06
Moves
42778
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hakaman
but does he want a father,
Sorry. I've never read his diary.

h

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
1772
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acemaster
Sorry. I've never read his diary.
never read the bible ? strange

A
Checkmate 2 U!

Checkmating you!

Joined
16 Dec 06
Moves
42778
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hakaman
never read the bible ? strange
Since when is the Bible God's innermost thoughts?

h

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
1772
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acemaster
Since when is the Bible God's innermost thoughts?
who wrote the bible

h

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
1772
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acemaster
Since when is the Bible God's innermost thoughts?
so when the bible describes the creation of the earth from whose mouth did it come from

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
(except by realizing that as God does not exist he could not have a father)
That's fallacious logic. E.g.:

Q: "Did Frodo Baggins have a father?"
A: "Since Frodo Baggins never existed, he doesn't have a father".

The question is whether the concept of "God" is incompatible with the concept of "having a father".

twhitehead

Cape Town

Joined
14 Apr 05
Moves
52945
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lucifershammer
That's fallacious logic. E.g.:

Q: "Did Frodo Baggins have a father?"
A: "Since Frodo Baggins never existed, he doesn't have a father".

The question is whether the concept of "God" is incompatible with the concept of "having a father".
Not as fallacious as you claim. Frodo Baggins does not have a father in the sense that no father of Frodo Baggins has ever existed.
The question "does God have a father" presumes the existence of God.

However, there is absolutely no point in discussing whether the concept of "God" is incompatible with the concept of "having a father" as neither concept is well defined enough to make conclusions about their compatibility.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
26 Jan 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
Not as fallacious as you claim. Frodo Baggins does not have a father in the sense that no father of Frodo Baggins has ever existed.
The question "does God have a father" presumes the existence of God.
Actually the title question is "Can God have a father?"

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.