Can God Make a Rock...

Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
"With God [b]all things are possible."
— Matthew 19:26

Is the Bible wrong?[/b]

Nope , your context is completely wrong. The quote is in reference to faith and was referring to ordinary people and ordinary lives not some far fetched abstract philosophical concept about logic.

Originally posted by wittywonka
Can God make a rock that's so big that he can't move it? 🙂

The answer to this question is yes - but he would have to choose not to lift it. He would be restricted by his own choice and will.

Originally posted by knightmeister
The answer to this question is yes - but he would have to choose not to lift it. He would be restricted by his own choice and will.

Wrong!

Originally posted by GinoJ
Wrong!

Wrong!

Originally posted by dj2becker
Wrong!

Wrong!!

Originally posted by GinoJ
Wrong!!

OK. Why do you say so?

Originally posted by dj2becker
OK. Why do you say so?

It's a paradoxical question my friend, meaning that you cannot answer this question yes or no.

It's like this: You have all the power to make everything possible, but can you make the impossible possible?

If you can make everything possible why cannot you make the impossible possible?

It is where your brain zeroes itself.

Originally posted by GinoJ
It's a paradoxical question my friend, meaning that you cannot answer this question yes or no.

It's like this: You have all the power to make everything possible, but can you make the impossible possible?

If you can make everything possible why cannot you make the impossible possible?

It is where your brain zeroes itself.

You seem to forget that if everything is possible for you it means that nothing is impossible for you.

Originally posted by dj2becker
You seem to forget that if everything is possible for you it means that nothing is impossible for you.

Then why can't God lift the impossible rock that he made with his own hands?

Originally posted by GinoJ
Then why can't God lift the impossible rock that he made with his own hands?

There is no such thing as an 'impossible rock' for God since he can do all things.

Originally posted by dj2becker
There is no such thing as an 'impossible rock' for God since he can do all things.

So god cannot create something impossible.

That's one imposibilty for God then.





ps:

I kiss you 😉

Originally posted by wittywonka
Can God make a rock that's so big that he can't move it? 🙂

can God rock, that is the question that is what we should be asking ourselves...............

Originally posted by Vladamir no1
can God rock, that is the question that is what we should be asking ourselves...............

exactly!

Originally posted by GinoJ
So god cannot create something impossible.

That's one imposibilty for God then.





ps:

I kiss you 😉

So god cannot create something impossible.

He sure can create a rock that is imposssible for you to move.

That's one imposibilty for God then.

Nope, since by definition God can do all things, it means he can do all things, which is the same as saying that there is nothing which God cannot do, which is the same as saying God can do all things.