Go back
Can you choose to go to heaven

Can you choose to go to heaven

Spirituality

Marinkatomb
wotagr8game

tbc

Joined
18 Feb 04
Moves
61941
Clock
15 May 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

[EDIT}- Title -Can you choose NOT to go to heaven

God gave us Free will. When we die, can we choose not to got to heaven? Assuming you have been saved and have been allowed entry, can you choose not to enter? If so, where do you go?

N

The sky

Joined
05 Apr 05
Moves
10385
Clock
15 May 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

That reminds me of Dostoevsky's "The Brothers Karamasov", where Ivan Karamasov says something like "I don't reject god, I just humbly give back my entrance ticket". Very interesting book, by the way. Anyway, good question. I think most Christians assume that the only alternative to heaven is hell. Not much of a choice, if you ask me. I guess refusing to go to heaven and choosing hell instead would make you kind of a martyr.

Actually I find it amazing how seldom this is brought up. Somehow most Christians seem to believe that if you believe in their god, that automatically means you will worship him. If I would believe in or even have proof for god as he is portrayed in the bible, I think I would become a rebel and, like Ivan Karamasov, give back the entrance ticket, should I be offered one.

Marinkatomb
wotagr8game

tbc

Joined
18 Feb 04
Moves
61941
Clock
16 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nordlys
That reminds me of Dostoevsky's "The Brothers Karamasov", where Ivan Karamasov says something like "I don't reject god, I just humbly give back my entrance ticket". Very interesting book, by the way. Anyway, good question. I think most Christians assume that the only alternative to heaven is hell. Not much of a choice, if you ask me. I guess refusing t ...[text shortened]... become a rebel and, like Ivan Karamasov, give back the entrance ticket, should I be offered one.
I am an atheist, but i believe in a creator/creators

I don't believe in Heaven for a second though. Were i to create the Universe and everything in it, i wouldn't expect worship from my creations and thus would have no need to reward or punish any action.

Personally, given the choice, i would choose to return to earth, or in other words, to be reborn where ever. I don't believe the concept of Heaven is realistic. Were you to live in a perfect world with no badness, goodness would no longer hold any meaning.

t
True X X Xian

The Lord's Army

Joined
18 Jul 04
Moves
8353
Clock
16 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nordlys
That reminds me of Dostoevsky's "The Brothers Karamasov", where Ivan Karamasov says something like "I don't reject god, I just humbly give back my entrance ticket". Very interesting book, by the way. Anyway, good question. I think most Christians assume that the only alternative to heaven is hell. Not much of a choice, if you ask me. I guess refusing t ...[text shortened]... become a rebel and, like Ivan Karamasov, give back the entrance ticket, should I be offered one.
Yes, it's amazing how many xtians claim that free will is necessary for a perfect world and that free will is contingent on sin being a legitimate possibility, but then in the heat of debate deny both that God can sin and that we can sin in heaven.

l

London

Joined
02 Mar 04
Moves
36105
Clock
16 May 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by marinakatomb
[EDIT}- Title -[b]Can you choose NOT to go to heaven

God gave us Free will. When we die, can we choose not to got to heaven? Assuming you have been saved and have been allowed entry, can you choose not to enter? If so, where do you go?[/b]
Your questions presuppose that we have free will after our death.

j
PapaJohn

South Dakota, USA

Joined
30 Sep 04
Moves
1783
Clock
16 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Interesting viewpoint, but you know, the demons believe in God. They rebeled out of pride and gave back their tickets a long time ago, but they believe, without worshipping.

The only reason one would talk about refusing to go to Heaven is if one had a cartoon understanding of what it would be like. It is, whatever else it may be, the fulfillment of our deepest purposes, of what it means to be human, and intensely interesting, as our intellects will be unclouded by sin, and we will be exploring the mind of God.

R
Acts 13:48

California

Joined
21 May 03
Moves
227555
Clock
16 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by marinakatomb
[EDIT}- Title -[b]Can you choose NOT to go to heaven

God gave us Free will. When we die, can we choose not to got to heaven? Assuming you have been saved and have been allowed entry, can you choose not to enter? If so, where do you go?[/b]
First off maybe that person was never truly saved.

Second, why would you not what to go to heaven?

S

Joined
19 Nov 03
Moves
31382
Clock
16 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by RBHILL
First off maybe that person was never truly saved.

Second, why would you not what to go to heaven?
Well after a lifetime of denial and living under a false free will, I'd be pretty miffed and as I'm only human I may be rash enough to have a go.

C
W.P. Extraordinaire

State of Franklin

Joined
13 Aug 03
Moves
21735
Clock
16 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by marinakatomb
[EDIT}- Title -[b]Can you choose NOT to go to heaven

God gave us Free will. When we die, can we choose not to got to heaven? Assuming you have been saved and have been allowed entry, can you choose not to enter? If so, where do you go?[/b]
No, and no.

Marinkatomb
wotagr8game

tbc

Joined
18 Feb 04
Moves
61941
Clock
17 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by RBHILL
First off maybe that person was never truly saved.

Second, why would you not what to go to heaven?
My point is this. Free will is the reason we sin. When someone kills someone, they do it out of free will. For heaven to be free of sin, it would have to be free of free will wouldn't it? Either that or your every thought would have to be monitored all the time to prevent you sinning in heaven. This may sound silly, but would that be heaven? (ie, a perfect place to be?)

Im also interested to know whether not wanting to go to heaven automatically means you go to hell, or if there is some kind of reincarnation for the un-decided.

Marinkatomb
wotagr8game

tbc

Joined
18 Feb 04
Moves
61941
Clock
17 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Coletti
No, and no.
Care to expand on that?

R
Acts 13:48

California

Joined
21 May 03
Moves
227555
Clock
17 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by marinakatomb
My point is this. Free will is the reason we sin. When someone kills someone, they do it out of free will. For heaven to be free of sin, it would have to be free of free will wouldn't it? Either that or your every thought would have to be monitored all the time to prevent you sinning in heaven. This may sound silly, but would that be heaven? (ie, a per ...[text shortened]... utomatically means you go to hell, or if there is some kind of reincarnation for the un-decided.
When we are in heaven we are there because we are covered by the blood of Jesus, and therefore we will not sin. And someday we will get new bodies in heaven.

f
Bruno's Ghost

In a hot place

Joined
11 Sep 04
Moves
7707
Clock
17 May 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by RBHILL
When we are in heaven we are there because we are covered by the blood of Jesus, and therefore we will not sin. And someday we will get new bodies in heaven.
you wont make it to heaven , if you dont undersatnd the word of the kingdom, and you have show a decided lack of understanding.

That you think you are already "saved" is enough proof of that.

R
Acts 13:48

California

Joined
21 May 03
Moves
227555
Clock
17 May 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by frogstomp
you wont make it to heaven , if you dont undersatnd the word of the kingdom, and you have show a decided lack of understanding.

That you think you are already "saved" is enough proof of that.
If it was not for Jesus dying for are sins no one would go there.

You don't need to understand it all, you are justified by faith in Christ. So come to Jesus, he knocks at the door of your heart Revelation 3:20, will you let him in?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.