03 Aug '08 14:25>
Originally posted by duecerMost work is done by theists.
Most religous orginizations do charity work, in fact most charity work is done by theist's
Most crime is committed by theists.
Originally posted by mazda9934A few things
Please bring to mind your image of God.
Then, please tell me why he allows very small children to suffer and die ??
(No one has EVER given me a plausible answer to this question)
Originally posted by realeyezDo you think 'man' is responsible for painful genetic defects like:
Since God gave us (man) free will, the question should be why does man allow little children to suffer and die.
Originally posted by Andrew HamiltonWhat would a world completely free of suffering actually look like though? Could freedom exist in such a world? Would men be free to make good/bad choices?
He also lets vast numbers of small children suffer and die across the whole entire world and does so because, like the rest of us, he is not “all powerful” and therefore doesn’t have the means to prevent such pointless suffering. “god” (if he exists) is supposed to be “all powerful” and so presumably has no such excuse.
Originally posted by knightmeisterThe answer - "Because I can't prevent it while also living my life, and I won't always be able to prevent it. I'm a limited human and so is he. I can't always be watching out for him and so he needs to learn to be tough and resourceful."
What would a world completely free of suffering actually look like though? Could freedom exist in such a world? Would men be free to make good/bad choices?
Christian belief is that one day God will end all suffering and pain and the world will be redeemed. The problem is on that day life as we know it will end too.
Regarding suffering one could u allow your son to suffer and feel pain when he falls of his bike when you could prevent it?"
Originally posted by knightmeister…Would men be free to make good/bad choices?…
What would a world completely free of suffering actually look like though? Could freedom exist in such a world? Would men be free to make good/bad choices?
Christian belief is that one day God will end all suffering and pain and the world will be redeemed. The problem is on that day life as we know it will end too.
Regarding suffering one could u allow your son to suffer and feel pain when he falls of his bike when you could prevent it?"
Originally posted by Andrew HamiltonPatently false, the vast majority of people on the planet are theist, so a representative cross sample of charity workers would certainly prove that the majority of charity is done by theists. I finds it hard to believe that the small (maybe 10😵 %'age of the population that are non theists are doing the majority of charity.
[b]…What about the child suffering and deaths we didn’t cause by lack of cooperation etc?
You missed my point; all suffering could be ended by co-operation, not that its caused by a lack of it. …
Don’t get me wrong; I am all for any cooperation that reduces child suffering and deaths. But, can any amount of cooperation prevent all child su ...[text shortened]... : in fact, there is reason to believe that most charity work is done by atheists -not theists![/b]
Originally posted by duecerSorry about that -that was a misprint on my part: what I meant to say: “there is reason to believe that if your are an atheist then you are more likely to do charity work than if you are a theist”
Patently false, the vast majority of people on the planet are theist, so a representative cross sample of charity workers would certainly prove that the majority of charity is done by theists. I finds it hard to believe that the small (maybe 10😵 %'age of the population that are non theists are doing the majority of charity.
Originally posted by Andrew HamiltonWhy would an all powerful but kind god be either unable or unwilling to so arrange the world so that every person is given many choices but those choices are all good choices that don’t lead to any suffering or potential suffering?------------hamilton-----------------------------
[b]…Would men be free to make good/bad choices?…
No, because there is no excuse for this “god“ to allow “bad” choices when giving us freedom to make choices!
Why would an all powerful but kind god be either unable or unwilling to so arrange the world so that every person is given many choices but those choices are all good choices that don’t lead to any suffering or potential suffering?[/b]
Originally posted by knightmeister…Because he wanted a world with real people who made real choices between good and bad and knew the difference between the two…
Why would an all powerful but kind god be either unable or unwilling to so arrange the world so that every person is given many choices but those choices are all good choices that don’t lead to any suffering or potential suffering?------------hamilton-----------------------------
Because he wanted a world with real people who made real choices betwe ...[text shortened]... he prefers his flawed humanity because it's the only way real love can be allowed to flourish.
Originally posted by Andrew HamiltonI have mentioned this before but generally we don’t “choose” who we love because what makes us love does not usually come from the rational mind.----hamilton-------------------
[b]…Because he wanted a world with real people who made real choices between good and bad and knew the difference between the two…
But why would he want us to have choices between good and bad RATHER than choices between various good actions if he is so kind? And if he is all-powerful and if he really wants as to knew the difference between “g ...[text shortened]... f the brain called the limbic system and its interaction with certain other parts of the brain.[/b]
Originally posted by Andrew HamiltonBut why would he want us to have choices between good and bad RATHER than choices between various good actions if he is so kind? And if he is all-powerful and if he really wants as to knew the difference between “good” and “bad” then why cannot he simply give a few HARMLESS demonstration that don’t cause any lasting or significant suffering just so we comprehend the difference? Or, even better, just feed this knowledge of the difference directly into our brains without causing any suffering! --------------hamilton---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[b]…Because he wanted a world with real people who made real choices between good and bad and knew the difference between the two…
But why would he want us to have choices between good and bad RATHER than choices between various good actions if he is so kind? And if he is all-powerful and if he really wants as to knew the difference between “g ...[text shortened]... f the brain called the limbic system and its interaction with certain other parts of the brain.[/b]
Originally posted by Andrew HamiltonA vegetable feels no love, happiness etc so obviously I wouldn’t want to become a “body snatcher”. But I also wouldn’t ever want the “flaws” in my humanity because my “flaws” generally make me less happy -not more happy! Love and happiness doesn’t come from “flaws” as you suggest here, it comes from the part of the brain called the limbic system and its interaction with certain other parts of the brain.
[b]…Because he wanted a world with real people who made real choices between good and bad and knew the difference between the two…
But why would he want us to have choices between good and bad RATHER than choices between various good actions if he is so kind? And if he is all-powerful and if he really wants as to knew the difference between “g ...[text shortened]... f the brain called the limbic system and its interaction with certain other parts of the brain.[/b]