Originally posted by realeyez
e do have reports of the gaurd, he was bribed and was instructed to say that his body was stolen. Matthew 28:11. The reason for the gaurd being there in the first place was that the Pharisee's heard Jesus say that he will rise, so they wanted a gaurd to stop his followers from stealing the body and saying look He has risen.
Methinks you rely upon a literal reading of Matthew -however the Roman soldiers would not actually have gone to the Jewish authorities (as Matthew 28:11-15 reports) but to the Roman governor, Pilate, to whom they were responsible. And according to Peter (11:43-49) the guard reported to Pilate.
In addition, Matthew's story about the guard is also out of order because it states that the guard accepted a bribe from the Jews, but according to our knowledge about the Roman soldiers it is extremely unlikely that they could be persuaded by any amount of money to take the risk of death for falling asleep on guard. If they admitted their sleep they just signed their own death sentences, and this is very unlikely. Also, if they had fallen asleep, methinks they would not have known that the disciples had stolen the body;
Furthermore, the phrase "to this very day" that is mentioned in Matthew 28:15 proves that the scribe of that gospel was writing many years after the events he was describing, therefore there was indeed sufficient time for the origin and growth of the legend of the guard. All in all, methinks these reports are pure myth
😵