Originally posted by dystoniac
Well, well, you had to go to your fellow atheists for assistance.
That's an odd thing to say. I took it here to Spirituality precisely in order to discuss it with believers to see to what extent they line up with you or distance themselves from you. What an odd way to open your post: an indication, I would venture to guess, of intellectual impairment perhaps?
Originally posted by dystoniac
The TRUTH really does hurt you, doesn't it...your post is proof that you have lost sleep over my statement...I think that's cool..
One could argue - reading this (above) - that you come across as a hateful person, sorry to say. You seem to take a certain amount of glee from the possibility of causing hurt and offence. And yet I certainly haven't lost sleep over this. My OP is an intellectual question and not emotional at all.
To a balanced, fair-minded person - including, it seems, some of your fellow believers - the stuff you come out with is clearly a form of hatespeech, "substantiated" only by your certainty, and not a shred of anything else. My questions are these: if you are truly sincere, are you entitled to some tolerance and leeway with regard to the perceived hatefulness of your words? If you were a person who had in fact lost his or her faith but continued to speak to others in this way, would your hatespeech become 'unforgivable', as it were?
I am not one of these people who believes I have the right
not to be offended. Not at all. Demanding that is anathema to free speech and is a silly
wet blouse type conception of 'human rights'. However your words go further. They are full of deeply personal insults, exhorting others to hatred, accusations of evil and satanism, images and threats of violence and gruesome death, asserting guilt by association with the worst kind of criminals, accusations of sub-human status or being a different "species", and so on and so on. This is vulgar, spiteful, intimidating stuff (or at least an
attempt to be intimidating). It seems to go rather further than an ordinary, healthy, knockabout trading of "insults". It is hatespeech, surely, and the onus is on you to prove it's "true" in some objective way (and therefore a responsible or legitimate exercise of free speech) or cease and desist, and keep the dark, swirling, manic machinations of your mind to yourself.
I return to my original question: does your sincerity and strength of belief absolve you from accusations of hatespeech in the realm of spirituality? And if your defence is merely "it's true" then surely you alone cannot be the arbiter of that. Surely you would have to be able to actually establish this "truth" in the minds of, at least, some moderate balanced practitioners of your own faith or other open minded, reasonable people?
Can we really scream repulsive, intellectually absurd, unsubstantiated insults and condemnations at each other, and then simply defend it by saying "I think it's true"?
And if the answer to that is 'yes', is it still acceptable to scream repulsive, intellectually absurd, unsubstantiated insults and condemnations at someone who does not share our personal superstitions, if, in our heart of hearts, we don't actually believe what we are saying? Does it become unacceptable in such an instance? Does sincerity give us the green light to spout diatribes of hatespeech?
Seventeen years living among Muslims, with many knockabout theological debates with various individuals along the way (and we are talking about people who are just as "certain" as you about what "the truth" is), and yet I have never, ever been subjected to the kind of unhinged incoherent loveless rancorous barracking that you seem to take pleasure from dishing out.