26 Feb '13 03:19>
I grew up in a three-times-a-week-to-Protestant-church-service family. In my mid-teens I realized that there were questions about a Bible-based belief system that I could not get satisfying answers to from anybody in the church. I drifted away from the church, and have classified myself as agnostic ever since.
In the decades since then I have had opportunity to discuss—debate, if you will—five Believers in an informal but in-depth way. I tried to show them problems with their beliefs, and they tried to defend their beliefs. The result in all five cases was that I came away just as sure that Christianity is false as I had been before the discussion, and as far as I could tell they came away with just as firm a belief in the bedrock truth of Christianity as they had before the discussion. In fact, one person I debated was a “Chreaster Christian” (attended Christmas and Easter services only), and is now an every-Sunday attender of Christian church services.
Have you had more success in persuading people to convert or deconvert (as your particular case may be) than I have had? If so, what seemed to be the argument that the other person found irrefutable?
In the decades since then I have had opportunity to discuss—debate, if you will—five Believers in an informal but in-depth way. I tried to show them problems with their beliefs, and they tried to defend their beliefs. The result in all five cases was that I came away just as sure that Christianity is false as I had been before the discussion, and as far as I could tell they came away with just as firm a belief in the bedrock truth of Christianity as they had before the discussion. In fact, one person I debated was a “Chreaster Christian” (attended Christmas and Easter services only), and is now an every-Sunday attender of Christian church services.
Have you had more success in persuading people to convert or deconvert (as your particular case may be) than I have had? If so, what seemed to be the argument that the other person found irrefutable?