Originally posted by FMF
You have aired your 'torturer God' ideology in public and it is being scrutinized, that's all. It is what this debate and discussion is for, after all.
Okay, I'll say a little about eternal punishment. Just a little.
This is my personal position on this dreadful matter.
Eternal punishment only makes sense if God is perfect.
Eternal punishment does not make sense if God is less just than His creatures. It makes no sense of God if faulty or capable of wrong doing.
Eternal punishment perhaps makes no sense if there is a higher God, say God 2.0 to which we can appeal who will correct God 1.0.
And probably eternal punishment makes no sense is it was not God Himself Who in Christ died for me.
If there is a higher umpire, a higher Governor or Court of appeal then perhaps the faulty imperfect God can stand some correction concerning punishing the rebel forever.
But then what if we don't agree with that higher court?
But then what if we appeal to an even higher court with a grievance?
Is there an infinite regress of ever higher Authroity? Is there an infinite regress of ever higher Love.
Where I am at right now with this difficult issue, is that eternal punishment only makes sense if God is the last place of Righteousness, Goodness, Love and Justice.
You objected very strongly to me speaking of eternal punishment as something like "perfect justice". Am I not sure what expression I used. But you objected.
I don't back down on that. It makes sense that the irreconcilable rebel must lose in the ultimate end. But where I am at these days is that this eternal punishment only makes sense as perfect justice if God is indeed the goodness above which a greater is impossible.
Now for a thought experiment let us assume that there are, let's say 18 thousand levels of higher authority and goodness besides the God of the Bible. If don't like any subordinate God we just bump up a level to the next higher level Authority to get a correction of an unjust decision.
Now what happens when we reach the last level - 18 thousandth Supreme Being ? And suppose we STILL have a serious revolt against that last level. Should we expect the LAST Supreme One, number 18,000 to say -
"Just forget about it. You can reject Me just like you rejected the 17,999 lower courts. I don't care."
To be punished eternally, as dreadful as it sounds, makes sense to me if there is no greater Rightness besides God.
It is His responsibility that when all mercy, forbearance, patience, and longsuffering has been rejected, the rejector is exampled as not being able to win against the Most High.
From what I have seen this is less of a concept to those who do not believe that that Man who died upon the cross was God Himself. I think what we need to see is that in Jesus Christ God Himself went
so far that we would be reconciled to God.