Originally posted by Marinkatomb
Consider this. I am a conscious being. When i was born, i was comprised of thousands of atoms which combined together to make me. During the course of my life i have replaced these atoms again and again, yet there is an essense that is non physical that remains (my consciousness). I am now a completely different person (literally) than the one who was bo f this line of reasoning is valid when deciding whether the Universe itself could be conscious.
Just to stab at this—
The cosmos is arranged such that conscious (and “self-reflectively” conscious) beings have arisen. That does not entail that the cosmos is conscious in any other sense, nor that there is a “ghost in the machine,” nor that such consciousness is less transient than any other physical aspect of myself. It’s transience is non-apparent under everyday circumstances because the bodily changes you mention occur within the general functioning/process of the system, and part of that functioning is to be conscious from a particular physical perspective—what you call “I.”
Absent that physical perspective—e.g., when your body dies—what is there to call “I”? Who/what is there to say “I”?
(Except for ease of speaking, I wouldn’t refer to consciousness as a noun at all—but rather, being-conscious as going-on.)
If it turns out the other way ‘round—that there is an actual substance of the cosmos called consciousness, or that that is the substance of the cosmos—even that still does not necessarily entail a continuation after death of the
individual conscious perspective identified as “I”.
_______________________________
Either way—
Imagine the cosmos—the totality, the all-without-another—as an ocean from which you have arisen, in which and of which you are a stream, a current, a ripple... A stream that is conscious of it’s own perspective of “I”. When you die, that stream disappears—but where does it “go”? What becomes of “I”?
Either way—
“Why should the water be afraid
to drown in the depths of the sea?
And how silly for the flame to fear
annihilation in the fire.”